The prose is so fluffy and hard to read. This is the first sentence:
> A shared, standardised communication protocol: it may sound technically complicated, but it is as simple as it is brilliant, and the technical blueprint has long been familiar to all of us: email.
The only visible text on the first screen is even less informative:
> A better internet for everyone is possible. Today. How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing? The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.
If this wasn't #1 on HN right now I wouldn't even have scrolled past the first screen.
The doc was written by Germany's Green party think tank (Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung). I first thought it might be LLM writing, but it might just be German habits leaking into English.
And the policy paper nails the important motives, although I miss some notes about why Nostr is not perfectly aligned with these values already.
Another critique: "We have identified five key challenges: infrastructure, governance, funding, attractiveness and
public mandate." - I wonder why network effect has not brought up.
Of course these are not very important questions, if a lot of money is already available as funding to keep the devs busy for the next 3 years.
> How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing?
> The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.
The short answer is that it isn't as profitable as creating discord. People's fears and anger are monetizable. The internet of the 1990s is gone. People don't share information just out of altruistic kindness anymore. Now it is all about selling a product.
> This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"
I tend to agree. It's further a bit insane that "businesses" are getting a say in the governance at all.
> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more
Yeah, the main thing we actually need is the elimination of bots and paid commenters. What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots. What makes twitter hell is the fact that it seems like 90% of the tweets come from bots.
> What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots.
If that's even true (I agree there are no _obvious_ bots), I think this is mostly a function of HN being niche enough. Any social network that addresses a large enough part of society is a target for ads/manipulation. It just comes with the territory. IMO the right approach involves adding a cost to spam.
Agreed, it's very frustrating that X enables the feature to see what country something is posted from (which accounts for at least 80% of bots), but does not enable you to filter your feed or view engagement / likes based on this same feature.
Of course VPNs exist but this would instantly solve so much of the bot problem.
Correct. I wanted to use BlueSky until I heard it was an absolutely totalitarian leftist echo chamber where you get banned / blacklisted for espousing the most milquetoast rightwing opinion.
I have to say to the downvoters I am an absolute bleeding heart leftist and I don’t know if I can disagree with this. I made an off-hand joke, pre-election, about a post wherein the user was horrified the Democrats would endorse Talarico. My gentle chiding was a variation on “no, not like that” when getting a Democrat of any kind elected in Texas should be a cause for celebration.
I got absolutely lambasted by that user as a DINO and by a couple of other accounts that smelled of bot farms.
That said, I fully support moderation of these tools. They theoretically exist to form communities. The fact grifters and trolls can ruin that is not freedom.
A recent 404 Media article suggested that at least Bluesky matched reality, while on X people were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.
> were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.
Are you an actual X user? Because people from both sides were instantly clowning on this, it was far from a consensus and the most popular posts were being meta / ironic
Humanity is a garbage fire, being exposed to the actual clash of ideas and cultures is much more desirable to me than a curated echo chamber of a narrow slice of permissable opinion (not coincidentally, also always the SAME slice on every other platform)
That’s not what X is. It’s a clash of ideas pushed by folks with bigger bot armies. The calm down after Yandex’s datacenters were hit should give anyone arguing for the cacophony a pause.
Sure but anarchy will not bring some sort of paradise, just like completely unregulated markets bring inevitably oligarchies and oligopolies/monopolies and not some happy long term balanced kumbaya. And where do you set boundaries is up to everybody's emotions.
Letting corporations milk dry anything good remaining in society is also less than desirable. And we know they do it simply because profit, and they will walk much further well into criminal behavior simply because profit.
Kids shouldn't read alone Mein kampf for example or racist xenophobic antisemitic etc things. Don't you agree? And that's regulation too.
1. Those who don't have enough of a moral sense to want to avoid it like the plague.
2. Those whose desire for money outweighs their moral sense - their desire for exposure to an audience makes X hard to resist. This includes corporations. The New York Times would have to give up nearly 60 million followers to leave X, for example.
3. Those whose values are aligned with the far right, up to and including MAGA, neo-Nazis, and the final boss of that mindset, Musk.
Arguably the first category includes the other two.
Hm, when IRL social fabric is overtaken by fighting we call that a failed state. I guess on the internet we call that successful tech economy? Why is that?
I'm desperately waiting for a platform which doesn't have bots, has rate limited participation, and has algorithms which aren't built to maximize retention.
In the meantime, it's mostly group chats, and me having to assume everyone else is either a bot or selling something (no worse than traditional media, but no better either)
I care less about the hosting provider, and more about trust and the impact on users.
Social media is the attention market. You only get that with stuff which either rallies or pisses people off.
Seems a broken idea. No idea if it can be solved so simply. Or if the solution is dedicated forums as of the past. Shared interest away from degenerative musings on things people will not properly engage nor meaningfully attempt to solve.
I think it's important to draw a distinction between social media that's for entertainment based mainly on content made by strangers, and social networking for sharing with friends and family.
Much of that activity has moved to group chats, but those aren't a good replacement for the experience Facebook used to provide.
All valid points. But then I also feel like very few people actually want to get a Facebook experience back. Most of my peers have stopped using FB apart from the bi-monthly check-in. It just doesn't fit the social experience we desire for most of us - and it was just popular because it was among the first social networks. I think FB occupies a very unnatural spot which is that you are friends with everyone from high school, university, and other things but at the same time you hardly ever wanna share stuff with all of them. Group chats to me at least seem like a much more natural way how we organize our relationships.
My experience was that first, Facebook transitioned from mostly being original content from people I know to mostly third-party content, then people stopped posting original content.
That has the same shape as spam. People don't want to participate when what they're sharing gets drowned out in a sea of noise. Of course the old experience required maybe 10 minutes a day to see everything, which is not a recipe for a profitable advertising business.
That’s a logical fallacy though. Based on what we have seen in the last decade or so, that’s been the case but it wasn’t always and there are plenty of smaller platforms. En masse doesn’t need to be the only answer.
You can think of that as a feature, not a limitation. The eternal September has been captured by Reddit, Twitter, Meta, etc. They won't invade the next generation of social networks. So those newer options won't turn into the garbage that the discerning have fled.
The policy document describes a future (in 2028) where:
...users decide for themselves which content, which algorithms and which applications they wish to use.
I think this is seriously mistaken. Most people do not want to decide for themselves which algorithms or applications they wish to use. Most people don't even know what an algorithm is, let alone how the algorithms underpinning most successful networks work. Making a proper selection of those will therefore require trust in others, and that trust can easily be derailed, as should be fairly obvious by now.
If you want to provide a better alternative, then anchor it in your government, provide it for free, and teach people early on that it is great. And don't forget to maintain your government as a properly functioning one, because your users will not see the difference with a dictatorship.
To solve this problem you need to acknowledge that the problem comes from both the right (the horrible underbelly of X) and the left (the suffocating dead-hand of Reddit and BlueSky).
Most attempts to solve this focus on only one of the above.
I don’t disagree, but each are very different problems with different solutions. I think it’s important to make that distinction otherwise both sides bristle at being likened to the other.
These initiatives are noble and good, but the seldom lack resources to compete with the giants. And many an times they become a victim of their own politics and ideology.
Your post advocates a
(X) technical (X) legislative (X) market-based ( ) vigilante
approach to fighting platform centralization.
Your idea will not work. Here is why it won't work. (One or more of the following may apply to your particular idea, and it may have other flaws.)
( ) Spammers can easily use it to harvest email addresses
( ) Mailing lists and other legitimate email uses would be affected
( ) No one will be able to find the guy or collect the money
( ) It is defenseless against brute force attacks
( ) It will stop spam for two weeks and then we'll be stuck with it
(X) Users of existing platforms will not put up with the inconvenience of switching
(X) META, RDDT, and DJT will not put up with it
(X) Requires too much cooperation from incumbent platforms and service providers
(X) Requires immediate critical mass and widespread ecosystem adoption
(X) Many users and businesses cannot afford to abandon established audiences and commercial relationships
( ) Spammers don't care about invalid addresses in their lists
Specifically, your plan fails to account for
( ) Laws expressly prohibiting it
(X) Lack of a centrally enforceable authority for cross-network governance and moderation disputes
( ) Open relays in foreign countries
( ) Ease of searching tiny alphanumeric address space of all email addresses
( ) Asshats
(X) Jurisdictional problems
( ) Unpopularity of weird new taxes
( ) Public reluctance to accept weird new forms of money
(X) Huge existing software, infrastructure and commercial investment in incumbent platforms
( ) Susceptibility of protocols other than SMTP to attack
( ) Willingness of users to install OS patches received by email
( ) Armies of worm riddled broadband-connected Windows boxes
( ) Eternal arms race involved in all filtering approaches
(X) Extreme profitability of incumbent platform business models
( ) Joe jobs and/or identity theft
(X) Technically illiterate politicians
( ) Extreme stupidity on the part of people who do business with spammers
( ) Dishonesty on the part of spammers themselves
( ) Bandwidth costs that are unaffected by client filtering
( ) Outlook
and the following philosophical objections may also apply:
(X) Ideas similar to yours are easy to come up with, yet none have demonstrated the ability to displace established platforms at meaningful scale
( ) Any scheme based on opt-out is unacceptable
( ) SMTP headers should not be the subject of legislation
( ) Blacklists suck
( ) Whitelists suck
( ) We should be able to talk about Viagra without being censored
( ) Countermeasures should not involve wire fraud or credit card fraud
( ) Countermeasures should not involve sabotage of public networks
( ) Countermeasures must work if phased in gradually
( ) Sending email should be free
(X) Why should we have to trust your alliance, governance structures and publicly funded infrastructure?
( ) Incompatibility with open source or open source licenses
(X) Feel-good measures do nothing to solve the problem of platform concentration unless users actually migrate
( ) Temporary/one-time email addresses are cumbersome
(X) I don't want governments determining the design or governance of my social communications infrastructure
( ) Killing them that way is not slow and painful enough
Furthermore, this is what I think about you:
(X) Sorry dude, but I don't think it would work.
( ) This is a stupid idea, and you're a stupid person for suggesting it.
( ) Nice try, assh0le! I'm going to find out where you live and burn your house down!
This feels like the ultimate "nothing ever happens" methodology to me. It's in the school of "nothing can ever improve, because if it could someone would've already done it". An avalanche of (admittedly generally real and well-stated) potential problems, of which you check 20% and claim it proves a point... I just don't think any plan to do anything ever would survive a methodology like this.
The prose is so fluffy and hard to read. This is the first sentence:
> A shared, standardised communication protocol: it may sound technically complicated, but it is as simple as it is brilliant, and the technical blueprint has long been familiar to all of us: email.
The only visible text on the first screen is even less informative:
> A better internet for everyone is possible. Today. How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing? The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.
If this wasn't #1 on HN right now I wouldn't even have scrolled past the first screen.
The doc was written by Germany's Green party think tank (Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung). I first thought it might be LLM writing, but it might just be German habits leaking into English.
Nice initiative! We badly want open social web!
And the policy paper nails the important motives, although I miss some notes about why Nostr is not perfectly aligned with these values already.
Another critique: "We have identified five key challenges: infrastructure, governance, funding, attractiveness and public mandate." - I wonder why network effect has not brought up.
Of course these are not very important questions, if a lot of money is already available as funding to keep the devs busy for the next 3 years.
> How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing?
> The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.
The short answer is that it isn't as profitable as creating discord. People's fears and anger are monetizable. The internet of the 1990s is gone. People don't share information just out of altruistic kindness anymore. Now it is all about selling a product.
> that strengthens democratic discourse
This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"
Yeah no thanks
We need less censorship / "moderation", not more
> This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"
I tend to agree. It's further a bit insane that "businesses" are getting a say in the governance at all.
> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more
Yeah, the main thing we actually need is the elimination of bots and paid commenters. What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots. What makes twitter hell is the fact that it seems like 90% of the tweets come from bots.
> What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots.
If that's even true (I agree there are no _obvious_ bots), I think this is mostly a function of HN being niche enough. Any social network that addresses a large enough part of society is a target for ads/manipulation. It just comes with the territory. IMO the right approach involves adding a cost to spam.
Agreed, it's very frustrating that X enables the feature to see what country something is posted from (which accounts for at least 80% of bots), but does not enable you to filter your feed or view engagement / likes based on this same feature.
Of course VPNs exist but this would instantly solve so much of the bot problem.
Correct. I wanted to use BlueSky until I heard it was an absolutely totalitarian leftist echo chamber where you get banned / blacklisted for espousing the most milquetoast rightwing opinion.
I have to say to the downvoters I am an absolute bleeding heart leftist and I don’t know if I can disagree with this. I made an off-hand joke, pre-election, about a post wherein the user was horrified the Democrats would endorse Talarico. My gentle chiding was a variation on “no, not like that” when getting a Democrat of any kind elected in Texas should be a cause for celebration.
I got absolutely lambasted by that user as a DINO and by a couple of other accounts that smelled of bot farms.
That said, I fully support moderation of these tools. They theoretically exist to form communities. The fact grifters and trolls can ruin that is not freedom.
Did you get banned though? Sounds like no?
A recent 404 Media article suggested that at least Bluesky matched reality, while on X people were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.
https://www.404media.co/republicans-learn-x-is-an-echo-chamb...
> were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.
Are you an actual X user? Because people from both sides were instantly clowning on this, it was far from a consensus and the most popular posts were being meta / ironic
The article is very much giving this meme: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/jessica-chastain-at-the-compu...
Wow that was a close one, you almost had to use it and make your own informed judgement!
I don't think the jury is exactly hung up on whether BlueSky is a leftist space where right wing views are not welcome
People that claim BlueSky is a leftist space would be shocked if they spend 10 minutes on Mastodon.
X is a garbage fire now, not sure why that is desirable.
Humanity is a garbage fire, being exposed to the actual clash of ideas and cultures is much more desirable to me than a curated echo chamber of a narrow slice of permissable opinion (not coincidentally, also always the SAME slice on every other platform)
> being exposed to the actual clash of ideas
That’s not what X is. It’s a clash of ideas pushed by folks with bigger bot armies. The calm down after Yandex’s datacenters were hit should give anyone arguing for the cacophony a pause.
Sure but anarchy will not bring some sort of paradise, just like completely unregulated markets bring inevitably oligarchies and oligopolies/monopolies and not some happy long term balanced kumbaya. And where do you set boundaries is up to everybody's emotions.
Letting corporations milk dry anything good remaining in society is also less than desirable. And we know they do it simply because profit, and they will walk much further well into criminal behavior simply because profit.
Kids shouldn't read alone Mein kampf for example or racist xenophobic antisemitic etc things. Don't you agree? And that's regulation too.
There are only three kinds of people on X now:
1. Those who don't have enough of a moral sense to want to avoid it like the plague.
2. Those whose desire for money outweighs their moral sense - their desire for exposure to an audience makes X hard to resist. This includes corporations. The New York Times would have to give up nearly 60 million followers to leave X, for example.
3. Those whose values are aligned with the far right, up to and including MAGA, neo-Nazis, and the final boss of that mindset, Musk.
Arguably the first category includes the other two.
If your moral sense leads you to avoiding ideas you don't like, like the plague, I think you might work on refining that moral sense
Is it not of some value to know just how many people think like that? Opposing views being of interest and all that… apparently.
X is heavily moderated, just not how you'd like it.
I fully agree. "Strengthens democratic discourse" is no more than a euphemism for "we can political opinions with which we disagree."
> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more
Based on what? The self-styled free speechers took the reins of American social media and made a mess with it.
must have a negative IQ to write this comment
Hm, when IRL social fabric is overtaken by fighting we call that a failed state. I guess on the internet we call that successful tech economy? Why is that?
I'm desperately waiting for a platform which doesn't have bots, has rate limited participation, and has algorithms which aren't built to maximize retention.
In the meantime, it's mostly group chats, and me having to assume everyone else is either a bot or selling something (no worse than traditional media, but no better either)
I care less about the hosting provider, and more about trust and the impact on users.
Social media is the attention market. You only get that with stuff which either rallies or pisses people off.
Seems a broken idea. No idea if it can be solved so simply. Or if the solution is dedicated forums as of the past. Shared interest away from degenerative musings on things people will not properly engage nor meaningfully attempt to solve.
Users will not move en masse to a social media platform that's not addictive. The addiction is why they are there.
I think it's important to draw a distinction between social media that's for entertainment based mainly on content made by strangers, and social networking for sharing with friends and family.
Much of that activity has moved to group chats, but those aren't a good replacement for the experience Facebook used to provide.
All valid points. But then I also feel like very few people actually want to get a Facebook experience back. Most of my peers have stopped using FB apart from the bi-monthly check-in. It just doesn't fit the social experience we desire for most of us - and it was just popular because it was among the first social networks. I think FB occupies a very unnatural spot which is that you are friends with everyone from high school, university, and other things but at the same time you hardly ever wanna share stuff with all of them. Group chats to me at least seem like a much more natural way how we organize our relationships.
My experience was that first, Facebook transitioned from mostly being original content from people I know to mostly third-party content, then people stopped posting original content.
That has the same shape as spam. People don't want to participate when what they're sharing gets drowned out in a sea of noise. Of course the old experience required maybe 10 minutes a day to see everything, which is not a recipe for a profitable advertising business.
That’s a logical fallacy though. Based on what we have seen in the last decade or so, that’s been the case but it wasn’t always and there are plenty of smaller platforms. En masse doesn’t need to be the only answer.
But a user who has quit existing social media might still find something there...
You can think of that as a feature, not a limitation. The eternal September has been captured by Reddit, Twitter, Meta, etc. They won't invade the next generation of social networks. So those newer options won't turn into the garbage that the discerning have fled.
The policy document describes a future (in 2028) where:
...users decide for themselves which content, which algorithms and which applications they wish to use.
I think this is seriously mistaken. Most people do not want to decide for themselves which algorithms or applications they wish to use. Most people don't even know what an algorithm is, let alone how the algorithms underpinning most successful networks work. Making a proper selection of those will therefore require trust in others, and that trust can easily be derailed, as should be fairly obvious by now.
If you want to provide a better alternative, then anchor it in your government, provide it for free, and teach people early on that it is great. And don't forget to maintain your government as a properly functioning one, because your users will not see the difference with a dictatorship.
i have a fear / feeling that social problems dont have technical solutions :/
To solve this problem you need to acknowledge that the problem comes from both the right (the horrible underbelly of X) and the left (the suffocating dead-hand of Reddit and BlueSky).
Most attempts to solve this focus on only one of the above.
I don’t disagree, but each are very different problems with different solutions. I think it’s important to make that distinction otherwise both sides bristle at being likened to the other.
Hah, on reddit "the left" i frequently see people discussing remigration: aka ethnic cleansing with nary a ban in sight.
We should start by taking away the advertising based monetization model.
yeah, that entirely defines the emotive based framing of clickbait because it wins when in competition with any other content.
These initiatives are noble and good, but the seldom lack resources to compete with the giants. And many an times they become a victim of their own politics and ideology.
This sounds like a less exciting version of Noster
These days when I see the word "social" somewhere online I read it as "anti-social".
ANProto will join this so-called alliance.
Not sure how they want to approach moderation.
Nntp!
Alright, whose data are we stealing now?
I dusted off the old form:
This is hilarious though a bit cynical, but has useful checks
stealing this, holy this is peak
I'd like to send you a paper. Mind sharing your email?
https://plaintext.world/#BEEHF1unzJlSD2ZHzK0HqD5CaOmIsTs0jHa...
Ref: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38365892
Claude recently proved that the NIST curves are safe too.
This feels like the ultimate "nothing ever happens" methodology to me. It's in the school of "nothing can ever improve, because if it could someone would've already done it". An avalanche of (admittedly generally real and well-stated) potential problems, of which you check 20% and claim it proves a point... I just don't think any plan to do anything ever would survive a methodology like this.
https://xkcd.com/927/