So, my view is that this is going to be mandatory for increasing the range of drone strikes. Wars like the Ukraine-Russia war will therefore necessarily lead to long range drones that fly further than the distance they can be controlled, and therefore there is no militarily practical alternative.
Problems that arise though, is that you can have incredible, worldwide oppression. Everyone agrees that it is sound to keep nuclear weapons out of other people's hands and it's easy to extend that logic to AI and drones too. So if you have this technology and others don't, then you might bomb them and their researchers to keep them down-- that's of course pre-emptive, but it's something we've tolerated in several cases, and although it might be against the UN charter, people do it. So one can easily end up with a situation where autonomous warfare technology is monopolized, and in that case since there's a persistent military advantage, it becomes appealing to use it to subjugate those countries too.
If people have to deploy soldiers on the ground or expensive aircraft, there is at least some natural pushback.
Nothing described in this dilemma is unique from nuclear weapons, particularly in the long-range case, where the dual-use cover of consumer and commercial drones becomes less tenable.
> Nuclear weapons cause immense harm to civilians that long range drones wouldn’t need to
Plenty don't. Tactical battlefield nukes. A strike on a naval formation.
For total strategic bombardment, yes, nukes are special. For everything below that, they're functionally similar to massive waves of drones in the way you describe. We're less in a brave new world than booting straight into suitcase nukes.
> Wars like the Ukraine-Russia war will therefore necessarily lead to long range drones that fly further than the distance they can be controlled, and therefore there is no militarily practical alternative.
This bridge was crossed in in World War II with invention of the first fire and forget guided missiles.
It seems novel because of drones, but we have had missiles that hunt target, loitering munitions, and cruise missiles that travel 2000km and pick their targets. These technologies have been around for a half century
.
The difference is that someone can buy everything to make a fairly sophisticated drone on AliExpress.
Historically, even well-funded and -connected terrorist groups have had to jump through major hoops to access even basic weapons, and high end weapons (“loitering”; “cruise missiles”) would have been far out of reach. This also applies to sanctioned nation states - Iran is using cheap drones, not high end cruise missiles, to wreak havoc in their region.
It’s the lowering of the technological bar leading to wider access that’s novel, not the concepts.
The economics and sheer versatility of it are completely different though.
It's one thing to pay a dozen million to down a jet fighter, another to pay a few hundred bucks to hunt down random soldiers, with strong prospects of eventually being able to hunt arbitrary targets for the cost of low caliber ammo.
I could literally by myself build and launch and autonomous long range drone with parts from AliExpress. it is not at all like a nuclear missile not even close.
Some things are worth failing just for the chance at success. Actually many things but that’s a different story.
I don’t want to overstate the seriousness of this specific issue but one can easily imagine humanity finding themselves in this kind of prisoner’s dilemma or some other “wickedly hard problem” where if we fail to solve the problem it might end humanity.
So I think we shouldn’t give up so easily and be so dismissive and say there was never any chance. I hope there will always be people who try to do things that everyone says will go nowhere, especially if those things are about convincing people not to kill each other (or create machines to do it automatically for them)
You wouldn’t know that unless you actually started the process.
This seems like an incredibly stupid criticism.
Also, why do you think drone manufacturers direct involvement would meaningfully change the result? They would obviously be advocating against any agreement.
A much more sensible approach would be national governments being represented and then talking to their drone manufacturers without the drone manufacturers being repreeented directly.
Somehow we manage to do nuclear accords without nuclear weapons manufacturers sitting at the table.
> You wouldn’t know that unless you actually started the process
I mean, sure, this arms-reduction effort could begin in a way that no other in history–from battleships to chemical weapons to nukes–has.
> why do you think drone manufacturers direct involvement would meaningfully change the result?
Sorry, I mean the countries that manufacture drones. A nuclear non-proliferation convention between non-nuclear states isn't entirely useless, but it's also hard to label as productive.
I think the best realistic option to hope for is for it to not be developed actively during peacetime. All bets are always off in war scenarios. Even limited wars have very high stakes where morals tend to go out the window.
The problem there is credibility, though. It's quite hard to verify.
> I think the best realistic option to hope for is for it to not be developed actively during peacetime.
No it isn't because then you and your allies are vulnerable to those who do develop it.
It's just more of the same crazy clueless self-important bloviating from politicians and bureaucrats and UN types.
It's fine to have wishes or ideas for how we think humans and societies ought to behave. It is not okay to permit anybody who does not understand how humans and societies actually behave to be anywhere near the reigns of power or decision making of any consequence. Which is why we send them all to the UN.
This is the type of response you get from someone who has had a nerve struck but lack the capacity to respond in a rational way.
Believing it is cynicism or lack of intelligence not to have a religious faith in "experts" and institutions and the ruling class has to be peak boomer mentality. Meek, subservient, unquestioning.
You may note that a possible agreement was only a "best realistic" case in the original comment. That does not proclude a worst case where such technology is constantly developed. You may also note that a major issue in the best realistic case (that it was hard to verify whether such technology was being worked on), was noted as a major issue.
I am not so arrogant as to believe I know all the possibilities. Your absolutist viewpoint shuts off even the possibility of negotiation.
Ukraine, or at least some of the contractors they use, have admitted to using autonomous drones in testing on the battlefield in targeting vehicles. They seem to be ahead of Russia on it and the fact that Russia is objecting to restrictions brings up interesting questions.
The USSR and the U.S. managed to strike several agreements under a similar situation during the Cold War, when hostilities between the two nations were significantly greater.
Huh? The Cold War between the USSR and USA (plus NATO) wasn't a kinetic conflict. Hence the name.
(There were a few Soviet pilots in direct conflict with US forces in Korea and Vietnam but that wasn't officially acknowledged by either side at the time.)
I may be giving too much credit, but I guess the two major powers of that period were at least intelligent enough to keep the Cold War cold and resorted more to indirect ways of coercion.
No shortage of kinetic by proxy conflicts though. Quite a lot of argy bargy in the Congo over ongoing access to and extraction of rich lodes of uranium for example (albeit rarely publicised as such).
But the standing back and avoiding direct one on one conflict of the two major parties did make big picture negotiation easier during those times.
What was it that prevented serious discussion at the recent trilateral summit?
Just keep building bigger and bigger nukes. What's with this unnecessarily complex middle step towards universal self-destruction? why build a rube-goldberg machine to shoot yourself in the foot?
We build industrial machines to do tasks that human hands cannot.
Even though they have no directive to harm you, industrial accidents happen that leave people dead and/or severely hurt.
What makes you believe that an autonomous machine built for adversity, with the ability to mass kill in an area (with autonomous movement options on top), won't have an "industrial accident" and accidentally shoot up half your army and civilians.
So, my view is that this is going to be mandatory for increasing the range of drone strikes. Wars like the Ukraine-Russia war will therefore necessarily lead to long range drones that fly further than the distance they can be controlled, and therefore there is no militarily practical alternative.
Problems that arise though, is that you can have incredible, worldwide oppression. Everyone agrees that it is sound to keep nuclear weapons out of other people's hands and it's easy to extend that logic to AI and drones too. So if you have this technology and others don't, then you might bomb them and their researchers to keep them down-- that's of course pre-emptive, but it's something we've tolerated in several cases, and although it might be against the UN charter, people do it. So one can easily end up with a situation where autonomous warfare technology is monopolized, and in that case since there's a persistent military advantage, it becomes appealing to use it to subjugate those countries too.
If people have to deploy soldiers on the ground or expensive aircraft, there is at least some natural pushback.
I don't see any solution at all though.
Nothing described in this dilemma is unique from nuclear weapons, particularly in the long-range case, where the dual-use cover of consumer and commercial drones becomes less tenable.
Nuclear weapons cause immense harm to civilians that long range drones wouldn’t need to.
It’s completely different from a nuclear strike.
Also, nukes can destroy the world, so it’s an obvious suicide pact. Autonomous drones won’t do that.
> Nuclear weapons cause immense harm to civilians that long range drones wouldn’t need to
Plenty don't. Tactical battlefield nukes. A strike on a naval formation.
For total strategic bombardment, yes, nukes are special. For everything below that, they're functionally similar to massive waves of drones in the way you describe. We're less in a brave new world than booting straight into suitcase nukes.
A nuclear weapons program has a much larger footprint and is harder to hide than an autonomous weapons program. The latter is mostly just software.
> Wars like the Ukraine-Russia war will therefore necessarily lead to long range drones that fly further than the distance they can be controlled, and therefore there is no militarily practical alternative.
This bridge was crossed in in World War II with invention of the first fire and forget guided missiles.
It seems novel because of drones, but we have had missiles that hunt target, loitering munitions, and cruise missiles that travel 2000km and pick their targets. These technologies have been around for a half century .
The difference is that someone can buy everything to make a fairly sophisticated drone on AliExpress.
Historically, even well-funded and -connected terrorist groups have had to jump through major hoops to access even basic weapons, and high end weapons (“loitering”; “cruise missiles”) would have been far out of reach. This also applies to sanctioned nation states - Iran is using cheap drones, not high end cruise missiles, to wreak havoc in their region.
It’s the lowering of the technological bar leading to wider access that’s novel, not the concepts.
The economics and sheer versatility of it are completely different though.
It's one thing to pay a dozen million to down a jet fighter, another to pay a few hundred bucks to hunt down random soldiers, with strong prospects of eventually being able to hunt arbitrary targets for the cost of low caliber ammo.
You already said the solution. Drones are cheap and extremely effective. Anyone can make them.
Yes, the drone, but not an autonomous drone.
I dont think this is going to remain an issue in the future.
I could literally by myself build and launch and autonomous long range drone with parts from AliExpress. it is not at all like a nuclear missile not even close.
Fast AI inference processors aren't something all countries can make.
Yeah, only Taiwan makes them. Doesn’t make them hard to get.
This will never go anywhere anyways. It's one of those "despite common sentiment", we're going to do it anyways because the enemy is.
Some things are worth failing just for the chance at success. Actually many things but that’s a different story.
I don’t want to overstate the seriousness of this specific issue but one can easily imagine humanity finding themselves in this kind of prisoner’s dilemma or some other “wickedly hard problem” where if we fail to solve the problem it might end humanity.
So I think we shouldn’t give up so easily and be so dismissive and say there was never any chance. I hope there will always be people who try to do things that everyone says will go nowhere, especially if those things are about convincing people not to kill each other (or create machines to do it automatically for them)
> Some things are worth failing just for the chance at success
This looks like bureaucratic time wasting. None of the drone manufacturers or users were seriously engaged at any point.
You wouldn’t know that unless you actually started the process.
This seems like an incredibly stupid criticism.
Also, why do you think drone manufacturers direct involvement would meaningfully change the result? They would obviously be advocating against any agreement.
A much more sensible approach would be national governments being represented and then talking to their drone manufacturers without the drone manufacturers being repreeented directly.
Somehow we manage to do nuclear accords without nuclear weapons manufacturers sitting at the table.
> You wouldn’t know that unless you actually started the process
I mean, sure, this arms-reduction effort could begin in a way that no other in history–from battleships to chemical weapons to nukes–has.
> why do you think drone manufacturers direct involvement would meaningfully change the result?
Sorry, I mean the countries that manufacture drones. A nuclear non-proliferation convention between non-nuclear states isn't entirely useless, but it's also hard to label as productive.
I think the best realistic option to hope for is for it to not be developed actively during peacetime. All bets are always off in war scenarios. Even limited wars have very high stakes where morals tend to go out the window.
The problem there is credibility, though. It's quite hard to verify.
> I think the best realistic option to hope for is for it to not be developed actively during peacetime.
No it isn't because then you and your allies are vulnerable to those who do develop it.
It's just more of the same crazy clueless self-important bloviating from politicians and bureaucrats and UN types.
It's fine to have wishes or ideas for how we think humans and societies ought to behave. It is not okay to permit anybody who does not understand how humans and societies actually behave to be anywhere near the reigns of power or decision making of any consequence. Which is why we send them all to the UN.
This is one of those comments that confuse cynicism with intelligence.
This is the type of response you get from someone who has had a nerve struck but lack the capacity to respond in a rational way.
Believing it is cynicism or lack of intelligence not to have a religious faith in "experts" and institutions and the ruling class has to be peak boomer mentality. Meek, subservient, unquestioning.
You may note that a possible agreement was only a "best realistic" case in the original comment. That does not proclude a worst case where such technology is constantly developed. You may also note that a major issue in the best realistic case (that it was hard to verify whether such technology was being worked on), was noted as a major issue.
I am not so arrogant as to believe I know all the possibilities. Your absolutist viewpoint shuts off even the possibility of negotiation.
Ukraine, or at least some of the contractors they use, have admitted to using autonomous drones in testing on the battlefield in targeting vehicles. They seem to be ahead of Russia on it and the fact that Russia is objecting to restrictions brings up interesting questions.
[dead]
Kinda hard to have meaningful discussions about this when the two biggest users and developers are at war with each other.
The USSR and the U.S. managed to strike several agreements under a similar situation during the Cold War, when hostilities between the two nations were significantly greater.
Huh? The Cold War between the USSR and USA (plus NATO) wasn't a kinetic conflict. Hence the name.
(There were a few Soviet pilots in direct conflict with US forces in Korea and Vietnam but that wasn't officially acknowledged by either side at the time.)
I may be giving too much credit, but I guess the two major powers of that period were at least intelligent enough to keep the Cold War cold and resorted more to indirect ways of coercion.
No shortage of kinetic by proxy conflicts though. Quite a lot of argy bargy in the Congo over ongoing access to and extraction of rich lodes of uranium for example (albeit rarely publicised as such).
But the standing back and avoiding direct one on one conflict of the two major parties did make big picture negotiation easier during those times.
What was it that prevented serious discussion at the recent trilateral summit?
Aside from the complete joke aspect of expecting anything much from Lame Duck à l'Orange: https://heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/p/november-20-2026
Of course it did. Autonomous long range weapon systems are the holy grail.
Just keep building bigger and bigger nukes. What's with this unnecessarily complex middle step towards universal self-destruction? why build a rube-goldberg machine to shoot yourself in the foot?
> Just keep building bigger and bigger nukes.
Why? Seriously, in what way is larger than a Tsar bomb useful, and for what?
> What's with this unnecessarily complex middle step towards universal self-destruction?
That presupposes the goal is universal self destruction. It isn't.
> why build a rube-goldberg machine to shoot yourself in the foot?
Ideally the machines are to shoot others in the foot in order to deny access to territory and other goals.
We build industrial machines to do tasks that human hands cannot. Even though they have no directive to harm you, industrial accidents happen that leave people dead and/or severely hurt.
What makes you believe that an autonomous machine built for adversity, with the ability to mass kill in an area (with autonomous movement options on top), won't have an "industrial accident" and accidentally shoot up half your army and civilians.