I think the layman's perception of the increase in survival (~13 months versus ~6 months) will make this look underwhelming. Nevertheless, it's important to remember that the incentives for clinical trials is to only include very late-stage patients who have exhausted all other options (faster trials, smaller sample sizes, surrogate endpoints, a shot at accelerated approval, ...). The fact that a treatment shows promise for these patients that are often in very poor health and considered "hopeless" by today's medicine is exceedingly rare, and the signal from this trial is indeed strong.
The (somewhat reasonable) hope is that patients 1. with earlier forms of pancreatic cancer (non-metastatic) 2. that can undergo surgery 3. together with a (neo)adjuvant treatment with these kras inhibitors, will end up having a much lower recurrence rate and a chance for a long, healthy life.
I think this is genuinely good news worth celebrating!
I have a friend who has a relatively good prognosis among pancreatic cancer patients but even still is facing the very real chance he won’t be here in 6 months. His wife gives birth to their second child in a month or so. I guarantee if it came down to it he would give literally anything to double his time with them.
“Man! Because he sacrifices his health in order to make money. Then he sacrifices money to recuperate his health. And then he is so anxious about the future that he does not enjoy the present; the result being that he does not live in the present or the future; he lives as if he is never going to die, and then dies having never really lived.” - Tenzin Gyatso
Caveat: a lot of people sacrifice their health to give others - their spouses, children, relatives most often, but often eventually also neighbors and community - health, peace, safety, opportunities, moments of happiness, a better start. All of which is purchased with money.
Without understanding this dynamic, the toil indeed looks like an absurd paradox. But the paradox is not in the reality, just in one's simplistic assumptions.
> Thank you for your email inquiring about this particular quote which has been attributed to His Holiness the Dalai Lama. His Holiness has made no such remarks, either in speech or in writing. We trust this clarifies it.[0]
Get a smaller house and a car that’s enough and don’t sell your soul to a boss who’s hoping the bonus he earns off of you misbehaving will buy his summer home.
Maybe read some Baudrillard. Most of our problems are made up and we chase analogs for what we actually want, and then we are made about it not being enough.
Lots of people doesn’t mean a high percentage. The 65.2% of Americans lived in a home owned by a member of that household in 2025, and significantly more people are able at some point to do so at some point in the future.
Meanwhile Lots of people are homeless or in prison…
America is fairly average in terms of home ownership rates. Slightly below Canada or Australia and well below Mexico, India, Pakistan, China, and many other far less affluent countries.
And part of that is greed by the owner. Tenzin isn’t talking about a straight line of individual decisions, or at least not only. We are affected by the odd priorities of everyone around us as well. The collective Man.
How about just have some awareness of the trap and not fall for the trap. The trap is in over spending, over consuming, over working. Find the middle way - and reject society who tells you to do otherwise.
Novelty seeking is very expensive when you let other people set the menu.
There’s a lot of stuff outside that’s still free or at least cheaper than a brand new SUV with heated back seats, and still counts as novel, or even informative.
Wake up early, prepare food, tend to the rice paddy, tend to the chicken coop, clean up, exercise, tend to the kitchen, read, pray, sleep. Often that ends up being a whole 14 hour day with not much time for anything else. Manual labor sucks.
I don't think that is the message. People do need to work and make money to support themselves and their families. But there are also lots of people who only focus on collecting more money to achieve some type of lifestyle at greater expenses then any dollar is worth.
My dad said to his doctor who was working 10 plus hours 6 or 7 days a week between 2 practices he owned "you don't want to end up the richest man in the cemetery". It triggered the doctor. He started explaining about how his kids were in college and he mortgage this bill and that bill. He was absolutely anxious and stressed despite making multiple times more then the average person.
So I believe the underlying message is more about work life balance. Don't spend your life chasing money that will leave you empty in the end.
We also work for people who are like that when we could work someplace else. So we end up doing charity work for their get rich (or out of perpetual debt) story while missing special events with family.
There was a great commercial years ago of a guy in front of a spruced up but typical middle class house, on a riding lawnmower, talking about his three cars, boat, and vacations, and then he said, “I’m in debt up to my eyeballs, please help.”
I grew up lower middle class, upside down mortgage, struggle foods. I’m really good at doing without things until I can afford them, until there’s a sale, rather than buying them on credit and paying for them twice. That’s how you end up running down a hill, trying not to fall on your face.
What I’m not good at is convincing a partner they can do this too. That a smaller apartment or house but in the same area would give us more freedom without longer commutes in the bargain. The struggle is real but you lose the moment you just relent.
I truly wish you the best. I once lived like you. I grew up not once going hungry but I knew at an early age that my parents were far from rich. But that gave me an awareness of money and spending it wisely. For a short time I racked up a small debt in my early 20s not understanding how credit cards can cripple one once they get out of hand. I spend years in debt and always stressed and anxious. When I finally got out of debt it was a huge weight off my shoulders. I didn't realize before how much it was draining me until that point.
Since then I have been careful and like you don't want to use credit for no reason and instead save up for the things I want then use my credit cards to get the rewards and pay it off right away.
But I too had a time when married where I was highly conscientious about finances but my wife was the complete opposite. We were always broke because it was one thing after the next that she had to buy. A new couch or new bed or needed the latest phone and so on. I let it happen and didn't take control. When we later separated and I had full control of my financials I have never had more money. I am not a scrooge and spend money on things but I don't like to waste it.
My advice to you is to find a way to set the rules and be assertive and not let her make the decisions. You are the one being financially responsible so don't let her pressure you into bad choices.
Don't take loans unless it funds a higher cash flow than the interest incurred. The only exceptions are emergencies.
The key is to hold off spending on things that you don't care a lot about. What I wear is mostly decades old. I buy new shoes when the current ones become unusable or too uncomfortable. I stay away from brands for the most part.
Most people would think that I live a miserly existence because my spends are not externally visible when I meet them.
But there are gifts. It allows for a bigger budget for travelling / hiking in the woods and the mountains. More budget for live blues bands that I love listening to but almost no one has heard of. More budget for second hand books and for buying supplies for hand made crafts.
Clarity over what gives one joy is gold.
Only thing is that I am an incorrigible ADHD afflicted hobby hopper. But over time I cycle back. All in all not too bad.
I'm really tired of hearing all these simplistic "capitalism bad!" tropes. Rampant greed can ruin any system. And I never see the tropes followed up by an actually competent discussion of what we should do instead, especially if we want to preserve basic individual economic freedom.
I feel what we need are working checks and balances and a culture that is less focused on flashing around personal wealth, not radical revolution that tries to bring on a kind of soviet union 2.0 or ... "something" that is somehow magically great.
That part is voluntary. I'm somewhat vehemently against consumerism as well as big business, but equally strongly in favor of capitalism. The main reason is liberty. If one thinks that e.g. communism is a good path forward then you're 100% free to try to create your communist utopia within a capitalist system. You don't really need much money to buy some land in the middle of nowhere to start your commune with some like-minded individuals. As an added benefit you'd even get a 100% free trade agreement with the US, for free.
But imagine the situation were reversed and we were in a communist system. Try to go start your own little capitalist utopia and it's off to the gulags with you. Perhaps that's hyperbolic, but not by much - you are required to play a role from the state in a communist system. And so if you happen to try it out and find it's not for you - there is simply no escape. This is where the old USSR jokes come in, like 'What do you call a Soviet quartet that's allowed to play abroad?' 'A duet.'
It’s not exactly “not being capitalist” to say “well you just need to buy the resources to not need the rest of society, or have enough money to trade for them!”
On a macro level you're right, but my reading of what they meant was more on a personal level, in the vain of "you're free to do your own thing". Start a commune if that is what works for you. Grab some like-minded people and have it your way.
I'm from Germany, and if you tried to "have it your way" in, for example, the GDR, you'd be in Bautzen in no time. The GDR inherited Bautzen straight from the 3rd. Reich.
I'm not saying every alternative to capitalism needs to end up this way. But I'm tired of hearing "capitalism bad" like we could just simply decide to "do something better". We tried, it ended just as horribly as fascism. The freedom to conduct our lives how we see fit necessarily includes (personal!) freedom of profession, freedom to trade and things like that.
People really need to watch the news broadcasts from '89, when the wall came down. I was only 10 at the time, and my family did not have any friends or family in eastern Germany, but thinking about it still moves me. The endless happiness of the people that their prison time has ended.
Same as any country or the countless communes throughout the US. Any society needs to make things. If you're not completely self sustaining then you export some of that and then import what you need to sustain yourselves. This is why I mentioned having a free trade agreement with the US already. You get to import/export whatever you create to one of the largest consumer markets in the world - for free. That's a valuable perk for free.
And in reality you don't really need to entirely disconnect from the capitalist world if you don't want. At least some people could maintain normal jobs, ideally remote, pool their resources, select a governing body to manage those funds, and go from there. This isn't like one of those mocking things - there are already many communes in the US, though none have managed to grow to a particularly large scale. But there's nothing stopping more people from trying it.
---
As for the land itself - there's lots of land available in the middle of nowhere for dirt cheap. Some of it's even freely available if you agree to build a house on it.
It's because most people prefer to live where there's a ton of businesses and consequently people within a stone's throw. Better job opportunities, entertainment, etc. All that then jacks local prices on everything, especially land, up to insane levels. If you're willing to live outside consumerville then prices on everything, again - especially land, exponentially decline.
You're probably thinking of free markets. Free markets are where the economy is free (it's in the name). Capitalism is where the economy is controlled by whoever has the most capital. Capitalists spend a fair amount of money trying to tell you that capitalism is a free market, it isn't.
Unchecked capitalism is in fact really bad, and the US's politics are so far right compared to anywhere in Europe that people yelling "capitalism bad" are hardly in danger of setting off a communist revolution. They might, if they're lucky, make someone think "huh yeah we maybe could tax billionaires a bit more without crashing the world economy."
So you just read the source and disagreed with the premise? I post this because the site is haunted by people saying they would never join a union because they’re three best developer ever and it would suppress their wages. At no point do they ever consider serious injury or health issues, falling in love and having kids, etc. having said that,
> preserve basic individual economic freedom
Where do you live where you have this? Because I trudge along in the United States well aware I do not have this in spite of making like $200k.
What source? I reacted purely to the quote you posted.
I live in Europe, make significantly less than you and feel like money isn't that big of a factor in my personal happiness. Sure, more would be kinda nice. But I'm mostly content with what I have.
But I meant "economic freedom" not in the sense of "I feel like I can do whatever I want because money isn't a factor", more in the sense of "there is no system in place that prevents me or my fellow countrymen from taking up this or that profession or even inventing a new profession" (for example). More in the vain of free speech, the freedom to make a living how I see fit.
But is has to do with how alternatives to capitalism might look like. They would, in my opinion, need to have certain characteristics. So far, I've yet to see a good one with respect to the characteristics I care about.
> Where do you live where you have this? Because I trudge along in the United States well aware I do not have this in spite of making like $200k.
Not the person you asked, but IMO $200k is an insane amount of money. I live in the US, was making a bit less than that (checked, inflation adjusted) and we raised a family with two kids and paid for their colleges while living a very comfortable life.
Both of us are immigrants of 30+ years and both are very frugal, so standards for "very comfortable" might be lower than what US kids today expect, but still. Not a criticism, but curious -- where do you feel $200k is not enough? I know SF and NYC are insanely expensive, but that is not the whole of the US. My 2c.
It feels like it would be better to determine what each of this “basic economic freedom” might be. I also wonder if your perspective is different based on being (it sounds) older than me. We are not living hand to mouth or one paycheck away from disaster, but I would say we are in what little remains of a middle class in the US. We have socked away a fair bit of money for our daughter’s college years, but not enough and we have socked away plenty of money for retirement but that particular goalpost keeps drifting further into the future. Our cars are paid off and not flashy, we aren’t spending on frivolities (at least imo). But we are working to stay alive and not a ton else.
The thing with Buddhism is the notion that many of our injuries are self inflicted or even conjured out of nowhere, and you just exhibited a top shelf example of that.
What I quoted has absolutely nothing to do with karma, and everything to do with how scared you are of dying with regrets. I understand the people who want to see their kid graduate. But just in general principle? Fighting for two more months when even more of that time will be in agony than if you did nothing, and spending your kids inheritance to do that? Why do we do that to ourselves? And why do we sign them up to watch? You can sort out your conflicts with your friends and family in a week, or you can’t sort them out at all. Car wrecks and heart attacks take even that away. At least a terminal illness gives you a last call.
Cancer is cruel. Cancer treatment is only less cruel, and still cruel enough that people volunteer to work in cancer wards to make the patients a little more comfortable (my ex signed up for one but couldn’t follow through).
“Time” is not a reason to stay. It’s a placeholder for magic thinking or something you don’t want to face. And when someone asks YOU what you want to have before you die, you’d better have an answer or you’ll waste it. “Time” is the answer you give when you don’t know the answer and you’re hoping you’ll think of it later. By the time you’re fifty you’ll already know that’s bullshit, or you’ll be buried having never suspected.
> everything to do with how scared you are of dying with regrets.
That's not the part of the quote people are objecting to. The biggest issue is the "sacrificing health to make money" part. Almost all jobs are not a significant strain on health. And a typical person isn't too anxious to enjoy themselves either.
“Almost all jobs”? Do you really believe that the overwhelming majority of jobs keep you safe from environmental and industrial pollution? Nevermind stress->inflammation->cancer pathways.
> Do you really believe that the overwhelming majority of jobs keep you safe from environmental and industrial pollution?
Your home and the places you visit outside work are also polluted. The threshold here isn't for almost all jobs to protect you, it's for almost all jobs to not make your exposure significantly worse.
It's pretty useless to talk about "cancer" as one thing. Many cancers do not "care" whatsoever about any of that. Even among the ones that do, I would be careful not to imply you can know anything new about a person by finding out they have a specific type of cancer. For one, it's almost always a statistically unwarranted leap, and second (more importantly), it makes you sound like a monstrous asshole.
Yes, cancer is complex. But in general it seems well established, that way of living does influence chances of getting some cancer. Apart from that, no concrete judgements were made.
And the "monstrous" post above was not at all about that, but about "sacrificing health for money, then sacrificing money for health, but never finding peace in the now".
General life advice. No one said as a general statement, "if you have cancer, it is your fault".
There are also people who see the protocol and hear the prognosis and say, you know, I’ve had a good life. How comfortable can you make me for the four months I have? And sometimes it’s six, or two years. I just heard of one that was three weeks.
It’s easier to accept when your bucket list is pretty checked off. And particularly if your kids are doing okay.
> Because he sacrifices his health in order to make money.
Yeah, no. People don't get pancreatic cancer because of this.
Blaming people for being victims of this terrible disease is offensive. Not that you did it directly, but it's still pretty much what this quote means.
The quote isn't blaming individuals, but humanity as a group. We have created an economic system that has polluted large portions of the planet and that has brought us to the brink of ecological collapse, and these collective actions have both created many of the diseases that we suffer from and the cures for them.
>these collective actions have both created many of the diseases that we suffer from
Okay, but cancer isn’t one of them. The Edwin Smith papyrus demonstrates that human beings have been dealing with it for literally millennia. And at the time that surgical treatise was written, there were no cures.
Cancer certainly existed prior to modern times. However this source[0] indicates that at least 42% of American cancer cases are attributable modifiable risk factors.
With that said, you're missing the point of the quote and my explanation. Slow down and take some time to think about it.
Additionally, we collectively hate bad news, so we procrastinate, even though we all know that early detection improves outcomes considerably. It’s easier to let the friction of the medical system convince us we can just do this later. There’s plenty of time later to do it.
If it's not blaming individuals, then it's crap writing. What does "he" mean, except for an individual? You seem to be adding meaning far beyond what was actually written.
As someone with plenty of chronic illnesses, I know how easy it is to cast blame, but, I've found, it's an extremely useless activity, and almost never productive.
In response to a discussion about pancreatic cancer, the quote was: "he sacrifices his health in order to make money."
If that's not casting blame on an individual, then WTF?
> I know how easy it is to cast blame, but, I've found, it's an extremely useless activity
Hang in there. My take on casting blame is that it makes some people feel less anxious about a capricious universe where some very bad outcomes hang on the cast of a die.
We have to take factors into account in order to limit the probability of negative happenstances, but the sad fact is that some people feel safer when they look at a homeless person, victim of crime, or a cancer patient and they think: this won't be me for X reason (I don't do dugs/walk alone at night/eat "chemicals").
It is a small step from that to go into a mentality of "he had it coming".
There is a conversational habit that many people have, of responding to a specific situation described by someone, with a generalization of that situation, or by bringing up one of their own similar experiences.
None of these responses are terrible, these responses are no doubt true. But in conversation, those are low bars.
These segues come across, and frankly are, very dismissive of the original particular circumstances brought up.
It is best to respond to specific situations, with something thoughtful and specific to them. The specific situation was not brought up as conversation filler or general smalltalk initiation, but for its specific import, so respect that.
Its an easy bad habit to have, but once it is recognized, it is fairly easy to break. And the result is people will find conversations with you much more thoughtful, caring, and pertinent.
Need examples beyond your own? Don't respond to the news that someone lost a leg with amputation statistics, or the time you almost lost a finger. Don't respond to someone's pain with trivia or tautology. Respond with specific comfort or help, or not at all.
I was one of these people- a few years ago I saw a video that showed people in "conversational stealing the moment" situations, and it became very (and embarrassingly) clear how I was probably making others feel. As you say, it was easy to adjust, though I still catch myself with the urge to jump in.
If I may pick a nit: I find that, in some cases, when a person shares an analogous story ("you lost a limb? Oh me too!"), it can very well be a sign of that person working to relate someone else's experiences to their own — empathy, basically. Not to be frowned upon.
It depends on the nuances of the interaction and, as we all know, text is pretty bad at getting across such nuance.
I'm not saying I mind your (just a pinch gatekeepy?) comment, but you know, there's lots of people out there, with different communication styles, and I feel it's generally good to assume the best of others' intentions.
That said, I do agree with the general "pay attention to how your words might be received" gist of what you're saying. Non-sarcastic smiley face (:
> If I may pick a nit: I find that, in some cases, when a person shares an analogous story ("you lost a limb? Oh me too!"), it can very well be a sign of that person working to relate someone else's experiences to their own
I agree that the motive is often a good one. An genuine attempt to connect.
But it is often perceived as making someone else's situation about oneself.
A bad habit like this one, doesn't need to come from a bad place. Just a lack of perspective. And it isn't a "hard" rule, but 99% of the time, if you keep the conversation on the other person's viewpoint, it is felt as support, instead of obliviousness or self-absorption. (Regardless of good motives.)
I would normally contentedly leave the thread there, but since you seem interested in such things, and since you have been generous sharing your background in another comment, I just want to put this idea to you:
I wonder if you have been (just slightly) repeating the same mistake, in a different way. I see you use words like "bad" and "good" on this topic; clearly you feel that some behaviors here are right and others are wrong. From your other comment, this seems to stem from your desire to avoid repeating your own previous mistakes. Maybe you wince at the accidental harm you caused in the past. And now that you have learned a lesson, you are trying to teach it to others. Good intentions (:
But I think that when you use a good/bad, right/wrong style of communication, it produces an unnecessarily adversarial tone, which can turn some people off to your otherwise nice advice. A "bad habit," as you might say.
In the past, it was:
Person A: XYZ
You: try to relate to XYZ, accidentally shutting down Person A. Oops!
Now, it is:
Person A: XYZ
Person B: PQR
You: trying to help them communicate, accidentally shutting down Person B. Oops!
Now, I don't know you. Maybe you really have interviewed a representative sample of humanity and verified your "99%" statistic. Maybe you really are in a position to judge right/wrong. But my sense is: probably you are extrapolating from your own limited experience.
So, in a similar vein to the advice you gave, I'm suggesting: maybe it would be more successful for you to simply share your knowledge based on your personal experience, rather than trying to generalize and map it to abstract concepts of right and wrong. Keep it specific and humble.
To be even more specific: rather than "I see you doing X. That is a bad habit and causes harm. Here is a better way to act ..." try something like "I see you doing X. I've had trouble with that in the past, causing accidental harm. Maybe consider this other way ... "
But of course, what I'm suggesting would be mealy-mouthed and milquetoast to some. Some people like to give more pointed, judgmental-sounding advice, and they would rather receive it, too! Less beating around the bush, and all that.
So, I don't know the right answer. I just wanted to put this alternative in front of you for your consideration. I think the reason I replied to your original comment was in large part because you said "These segues come across, and frankly are, very dismissive ..." and I read that as an unnecessarily harsh and judgemental thing to say, despite your generally reasonable advice, and your certainly good intentions.
But anyway, I have enjoyed this interaction with you — clearly you care about other people, and your effect on them. I think our souls are similar, here (:
(Hopefully it is clear that my spiel above is very small peanuts and nuance-upon-nuance; I don't mean it to sound berating. Just offering another tool for you toolbox.)
Every conversation I ever had where someone brought up an incident that had serious meaning to them, and I immediately and habitually brought up a comparable one of my own. Or worse, a similar situation I had heard of. Thinking I was saying "I understand", when what gets perceived is "The situation that is bothering them involves nothing unique or worthy of my focused attention". Hundreds of such conversations at least.
As a sibling commenter points out, the motive is often a genuine attempt to connect. It just happens to be inept.
My point isn't to shame. But to avoid the negative impact, or lost positive impact, due to missed nuance.
Someone had to point out this common communication misfire to me too.
When someone is sharing something, connecting and demonstrating understanding is much more successful by showing you are focused on what they said, and their situation, not a generalization or free associated version of it. And especially not turning things toward oneself or some abstract other.
Creative people can almost always think of something comparable in some way, that they experienced. But did we really need to talk about that? Obviously not, since we had to be prompted. But the person whose situation prompted us felt the need to bring up their situation. Put their expressed need first.
They are sharing a need to talk about something serious and specific.
When someone is sharing anything painful, this is especially true.
I am not saying never bring up one's own experience. Once the dynamic is recognized, its usually easy to tell the difference between someone sharing something serious, vs. just chatting about something. And the difference between a "me too" reflex vs. sharing an experience that offers some genuine insight or help. Even then, staying focused on their experience will be appreciated as care and attention given.
--
Specific example, made up but typical:
When someone says "My mother died", the best response isn't "that's tough, I lost my mom too", or "that's bad, and it happens to all of us", it is "I am so sorry, were you close? Tell me about her." They brought up their mom, their loss. Show you care by keeping your focus on their mom and their loss. Encouraging them to share as much as they need to.
Their mom was a special person. Not an example mom or "like" another mom, just because other people have lost moms.
There is no "comparable" mom or loss, and even an inadvertent implication along those lines is inaccurate, insensitive. and tends to shutdown that line of conversation prematurely.
"I guarantee if it came down to it he would give literally anything to double his time with them."
I'm deeply sorry about your friend, but I guarantee that this is not true. Nobody will give 'literally anything'. All his money? His house? His children's health?
Of course not. There is always a tradeoff in any treatment. My wife has chosen to stop the treatment that may have given her a few more months because those months would have been spent with the permanent side-effects of that treatment - nerve damage in this case. She would have no longer been able to paint, or cook, or enjoy what time she has left to her.
I would give up all my money and my house to double my remaining lifespan.
I don't have children and if I did I wouldn't give to their health, but that's a matter of trading several lifespans for one, it's a bad trade no matter how much you value a lifespan compared to other things.
When a family has a pancreatic cancer diagnosis and they have to get all things in order in a hurry, the difference between 6 months and 13 months is immense.
Maybe I'm being clueless, but surely if the median survival time goes from 6 months to 13 months, the most likely way for that to happen would also be for a higher percentage of people to survive indefinitely - say, beyond five years? It would be weird if we had this existing life expectancy distribution with the median of the distribution at 6 months, and the pill pushed a ton of distribution mass to get the median to 13 months, and it somehow did that without getting more people to 2 years, 5 years, 10 years, ...
> surely if the median survival time goes from 6 months to 13 months, the most likely way for that to happen would also be for a higher percentage of people to survive indefinitely - say, beyond five years?
There's no way to know, unfortunately, but the trial data suggests otherwise [1]. This story is about anecdotes, and you should basically ignore it.
The trial for daraxonrasib was 16 months, with a median follow-up of 8.5 months, and the median progression-free survival in that trial was around 7 months. From this data alone, you can't really say anything about longer-term survival, but most patients appear to relapse well before 5 years.
Of course, that's still a benefit for a cancer where there's essentially no other options.
most of these phase iii cancer treatment studies look at median overall survival and usually it's an underwhelming single digit increase in months of life extension with varying quality of life.
it's a hard problem, sure, but i still think there should be endpoints that measure total remission or durable halt of progression and that words like "breakthrough" should be reserved for when those endpoints are met.
sure, but i looked into this a bunch for mcrpc sometime back and it was the same thing. i suspect once it metastasizes it's pretty much the same story, there are a couple of hacks that can slow it down for a few months, but nothing really stops it.
i often wonder if a fundamentally new approach is needed. rather than static compounds and long drug trials, some sort of mechanism for establishing some safety properties rapidly and on demand (in vitro?) and then something that looks more like closed loop high frequency monitor and adjust customized interventional therapies that are synthesized and customized on the molecular level.
the mrna dream, but actually doing it, probably with ai and in vitro safety testing, probably.
Since many treatments are on an asymptotic curve where the x-axis is how early the cancer was detected, I am sure that the usual hope when looking at one end of the curve is that it projects back in time with something approximating the other protocols that already exist.
Of course the fact that every curve is different is why every patient needs a consultation to decide if surgery, radiation, or chemo are your first stop. Because for people in this range of progression, surgery is less dangerous than chemo. And perhaps radiation to shrink the tumor first will make the tumor operable, which it currently isn’t because of what it’s right next to.
Or if it’s metastatic, maybe all three for different tumors. Excise this lymph node, radiation for the brain, etc.
An it's really important to note that the trend is important too where this is the worst it will ever be.
For someone who's life expectancy after x time doubles, it also means there's more time for more treatments or innovations in treatments because of the time increase.
From what I understand many cancer patients annd particularly their families are fairly attentive to treatments that are currently in late phase trails.
Unfortunately the problem is somewhat a Devil You Know. We know the consequences and the odds of old treatments, the new ones we don’t even know all of the consequences. So it’s easier to think of them as a miracle.
Of course old and frail people tend to die when they lose hope, so the placebo effect of something on the horizon, from a new treatment to your youngest’s graduation, is important.
My grandfather died of pancreatic cancer when I was two years old. If he had had another seven months, I might have little fragments of memories of him.
> I think the layman's perception of the increase in survival (~13 months versus ~6 months) will make this look underwhelming. Nevertheless, it's important to remember that the incentives for clinical trials is to only include very late-stage patients who have exhausted all other options (faster trials, smaller sample sizes, surrogate endpoints, a shot at accelerated approval, ...).
I think your perception of perception is irrelevant and wrong.
A wisdom I am forever thankful that was repeatedly ingrained in me was the importance of time. So many of my elderly clients constantly said no matter what spend as much time as possible with my kids as they were young. And I did.
Several years back my niece was diagnosed with brain cancer at like 10-11 years old. She died at the age of 12. It crushed me. I couldn't imagine how my cousin could carry on but she had other kids that needed her. I am certain she would give everything she owns for another hour with her baby.
Even if this medication only gives you a couple extra minutes for me I would consider it priceless. I would be sad to learn if the average layman actually considered and extra 7 months as underwhelming.
The majority of people who get pancreatic cancer are relatively old. As someone pushing 60, I've probably got 20 years left, if something doesn't get me first. There's no cure for that! As you get older your perspectives change. I've accepted my remaining time is limited, but I'll take what I can get. I can guarantee you I'd be very happy for a longer survival rate if I had cancer right now - even a year is a significant fraction of my expected remaining life.
I also think this is great news, but I am also curious as to the side effects. When Ben Sasse was interviewed a few months ago while taking this drug, he had lots of bloody wounds and scars on his face which he said was a side effect of the drug.
That said, the drug reduced his tumor volume by 76% and he said it really improved his quality of life, so it still definitely sounds like great news, but I'm just wondering if the drug caused that many visible side effects if there are internal side effects that would wear down the body over time.
This is really big deal because pancreatic cancer’s low survival rate is due in large part to how late it’s often noticed. Is’s very difficult to spot it early, as there may be no symptoms.
My father died of pancreatic cancer. Well actually he died from the chemo thatw as treating his cancer. They said it would give him a year vs sic months but he died in a month. So I would say this would have been a better option.
Saying that, is it better to live longer knowing you are going to die just a little later? I would just advise people to prepare now for the idea of your death. Memento mori...
But the science, this is a RAS inhibitor which stops GTP from binding to the RAS enzymes which basically slows cell division. Many gene polymorphisms that sloe down RAS activity lead to these cells that are mutated to create higher RAS activity. (I think this is important.)
The GTP is also important before you get the cancer since low GTP will inhibit DNA repair.
> is it better to live longer knowing you are going to die just a little later?
When deciding what to do today, we all know we have a limited number of days left and should not waste them. Sure 50 years is more than 6 months, but it doesn't change the fact that wasting time is a silly idea for everyone.
It is a big mystery to me why people are so bad at choosing what to do with their time compared to their stated goals. Nobody says "next weekend I plan to binge watch netflix and not get out of bed", yet many do exactly that.
I couldn’t disagree more! Doing a bad thing is a bad way to spend time by definition; therefore “no bad way to spend your time” suggests there are no bad actions.
History is replete with truly abhorrent counterexamples. One can certainly spend time badly.
If nobody had ever created a computer virus we’d be far less prepared for people to start writing them.
As such even ‘abhorrent’ uses of one’s time can have long term positive outcomes. Which means we don’t have enough information to actually rank outcomes only heuristics.
Modern medicine has ensured that a greater portion of our voter base has dementia. Cancer's victims are 90% the elderly. The leadership they choose leads to more deaths around the world than curing cancer saves.
For once, this isn’t hyperbole. Metastatic pancreatic cancer hasn’t had a meaningful new treatment in literally decades - it’s been brutal chemotherapy or slightly less brutal chemotherapy.
The new generation of KRAS inhibitors, of which daraxonrasib is just the first to make it to approval, is genuinely a practice-changing breakthrough.
It won’t cure people with metastatic disease, but it will help a lot live better lives for longer.
>Metastatic pancreatic cancer hasn’t had a meaningful new treatment in literally decades
Not true. The folfirinox chemo regimen was invented a couple of years ago, and it significantly increased the life expectancy and quality of life for terminal pancreatic cancer patients.[0]
FOLFIRINOX was first used in Pancreatic Ca before the millennium, and the paper you linked to (which proved the benefit in a proper phase 3 trial) was published in 2011 - so >1.5 decades ago.
Progression-free survival increased from 3 months to 6 months.
(overall-survival increased from 7 months to 11 months).
Both statistically significant, and at the cost of increased toxicity during those additional 3 to 4 months of “’significantly’ increased life expectancy”
Downvoted for mentioning that the life expectancy for metastatic pancreatic cancer was recently doubled. Apparently this new drug can't just be an advance, it has to be unprecedented, unique, and of course worth any price.
This is absolutely NOT hyperbole, this has been an intractable disease for deacades, and the very first trial to show improvement is a lower bound on how effective the drug will be, not a full estimate.
First, this is a brutal drug, very hard to tolerate, and as better ways are found to manage side effects and to dial in the dosing, the treatment effects will increase.
Further, this is in metastatic pancreatic cancer, a stage of the disease where virtually all hope of a cure is gone for most. Any progress here will translate into bigger gains in earlier stages of the disease. We test new unproven therapies in metastatic cases like these because all other better options have been exhausted. And for decades, all those trials have been failures, this is the first time something has worked at all.
Additionally, this is just the first drug showing how to go after KRAS. Follow-on drugs, which some people call mere "me-too" drugs, will improve efficacy, have fewer side effects, and be more tolerable, all improving real-world results.
And as we learn to make KRAS treatments more tolerable, we'll also learn about how best to combine them with other existing chemotherapies, which requires lots of testing. Go to ASCO, and you'll see trial after trial after trial of small variations, trying to continuously improve existing treatments. It's a slow and brutal way to learn, but it's all we've got.
So if you only look at 13.2 months versus 6.7 months, yes, you are missing something! This is like discovering a whole new vein of gold ore to mine. We don't know where it will lead or how big it is, but what we can see right now is far far more than 13.2 / 6.7.
> Doubling life expectancy on a form of cancer infamous as a death sentence.
Would you say the same thing if it were doubled from five minutes to ten minutes? Who cares about doubling? It's the 7.5 months that's the point. And 7.5 months is what it is.
I'm sure whoever has it would be grateful for every extra day, and so would their family. I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish by writing this comment, but you just seem pedantic.
Knowing you are going to die in six months puts a huge toll on the family and the patient. I do not know if four more months of this toll would be worth it after seeing what my father went through in his one month of knowing this.
More time means more chances for people to travel, to see family who is stuck because of life circumstances, to make it to a wedding that you wouldn't've if you only had 6 months.
If all of you guys are fine with giving up those last few months, then give it to me and the others who want to soak up every last moment of life.
Sorry to hear about your father. I lost both my parents and an uncle to cancer, and am a survivor myself. So I speak from experience.
Extra months (quality of life aside) buys time while treatment research continues at an accelerating pace. Also, I haven't seen the distribution curve but the _median_ increasing by several months implies a small effect for some individuals but possibly multiple years for others. It's a big f'ing deal.
Clinical medicine works with averages, but the outliers matter, because they are literal human lives.
There will be patients who won't even see that doubling, but there may also be patients who will go into permanent remission because of this drug. And we may study them, discover the reason why they respond so well, and try new approaches based on those discoveries.
BTW 5 vs 10 minutes is a non-trivial difference in emergency medicine. An easily deployable treatment that would prolong survival of brain cells in hypoxic conditions from 5 to 10 minutes would matter a lot when bringing critical patients into hospitals. So, your example of absurdity may well be non-absurd in certain real world context.
Often pancreatic cancer is discovered only after it has spread. If this can treat it at that point it turns the disease from a death sentence to a lifeline until more research can come to fruition
If you'd taken that view on battery capacity you'd be happy with a smart phone that weighs as much as a brick and lasted 20 minutes fully charged.
I played with RC cars back in the 90s, 1200mAh was considered beefy before NiMh came and bumped it up slightly. Now we have lithium batteries with several times that capacity in the same form factor.
Most of that came from chipping away at it. Yes new technology got introduced but in the beginning they were not decisively superior, they had to be refined and improved little at a time.
Perhaps we'll find a miracle cure that fixes everything, maybe we have to chip away at it and get half a year here, another year there.
Our lives are short anyway. You might as well be saying none of it is worth it.
If I had a choice between an average of 6 or 13 months, I'll take the 13.
And who knows, maybe they can refine the approach or improve screening for earlier detection or something and get it higher for future patients. This could be just the beginning.
I have a close relative currently in the last stage of a different type of cancer, would be pretty happy to extend their life by another six months. Or even better, improve quality of life because what I'm seeing is no life at all. This might or might not be a breakthrough by some strict definitions of the term, but sure is for those for whom it is important.
Breakthroughs can be incremental and still have an impact. A little bit at a time eventually leads to a great things. It also speaks as to how hard the challenge is. We tend to appreciate things more when they are limited. That's true for the days in our lives too. Any amount of time is great and it's greatly appreciated.
Quality of life on chemotherapy is not great. Sadly, I know this firsthand through my father. I hope it gets approved in my country in time to reach him, even if it only gives him another year and a half.
It's very important to make sure the kids are left with nothing.
edit: If you asked me if I would like to live 7 more painful months for $40K/month, I'd at first think you were joking, and then I'd think you were insane. Of course not. Give 14 kids a full scholarship in my name.
We're putting a lot of effort into making sure that people leave this world completely drained of every penny.
It is telling to me that this gets down voted. Many people here are of the "I me me me mine" mindset, and being down voted for your comment reveals this.
Here you are, sacrificing your own life to make others lives better and peoiple here are like; "Nah..."
Everything is relative. A few more months of life with less pain and more energy to spend it with family surely is a breakthrough for many patients and for the doctors treating them.
You're awfully negative about what a lot of people here see as a breakthrough. Can you be more descriptive about why you don't agree this constitutes a substantial difference other than saying you disagree and dismissing others' opinion?
(not the op) Well, while I understand how fiendishly difficult is to make any progress on cancer and in this type of cancer in particular; and how important is for anyone to be able to add a few months to their life; still I would call something that merely delays your death by 6 months a major improvement but not exactly a breakthrough. A breakthrough is usually something that either solves a problem or at least indicates a new road towards a solution.
Or, more realistically, you emerge in the dark, unaware of your new territory, equipped with the tools that got you this far and everything you need to analyze what actually worked with that first prison wall.
You've broken through into the unknown, and maybe there's a fresh wall of unknown composition, but maybe the tools that got you this far can get you further if tweaked.
I don’t think you have ever had to witness somebody undergoing chemotherapy. An alternative, if available is almost always better, and certainly less painful.
You might as well be antinatalist and there's nothing wrong with that IMO but it otherwise yeah life is of suffering, and until science and politics resolves that we're going to be suffering and dying left and right
this is like saying Wright brothers didn't make a breakthrough in 1903.
yes, median survival only increased by 7 months, yes, the quality of life is not mentioned. but we are talking about the most lethal cancer at stage 4. the exact same brutal condition that didn't see any treatment improvements for decades.
> Treatment-related adverse events that led to treatment discontinuation occurred in 1.2% of the patients in the daraxonrasib group and in 11.2% of those in the chemotherapy group.
That's a huge reduction in side effects bad enough to stop treatment.
At the February 2026 data cutoff (median follow-up of 8.5 months), the median overall survival for daraxonrasib was 13.2 months, with a 95% confidence interval of 10.0 months to "not estimable". In contrast, the chemotherapy group's survival data had matured enough to lock in a tight confidence interval of 5.8 to 8.0 months.
So, it could be that the new drug is much much better, but they couldn't tell at the time because they only were trying to say that it was significantly better then chemotherapy.
I think one of the other things the comments I’ve read so far is missing: we rest patients between rounds of treatment to allow time to recuperate. Even surgery and radiation are rough. Chemo is discontinues when your vitals slip too far, and when your time is too short.
Anything that extends your time could allow another round of treatment, with its own over/under that gets you a little more time. So there should be a bit of compound interest here.
Chemotherapy is very general, this is possibly the first major step towards a cure and massively reshapes the research landscape. From here only time will tell whether this is a dead end or the first major step.
> It won’t cure people with metastatic disease, but it will help a lot live better lives for longer.
Cancer is a problem that can be solved, and it needs to be solved asap. Cancer too often gets either relegated to "Actually, statistically it's very unlikely" by people who don't have it or stylized to the God of Death that unlike other illness we won't solve anytime soon. There is no time to be lost tackling with AI. Dario gets it. Had cancer himself and his father passed away from it.
The thing that makes cancer such a hard problem is that cancer is really a collection of diseases. There's, what, like over a hundred of them? And one organ can produce several unrelated cancers too. I do hope AI will actually be able to figure out the commonalities between all of them and a potential path for a possible even somewhat-universal solution, but I at least don't even know if a universal "cure" is even possible. Granted, my knowledge of biology with respect to cancers is pretty limited.
This is exactly the mindset I meant. Look up how people dismissed Neuralink 5 years ago and now it's precise enough to play GTA via. A month ago Tao prognosed that the Riemann hypothesis will be solved in the next 25 years.
I think you misunderstood what youre replying to. They're not saying cancers aren't worth fighting, they're saying cancer is not one thing. Theyre replying to the thread that started with "cancer needs to be solved asap", which isnt true or possible because The Cancer Disease doesn't exist.
What's your sense for FTL without time dilation effects?
I mean I get you but the problems you mention are specific to this Earth based middle ground we emerged into.
Others are likely so fundamentally linked to forces we cannot overpower due to the immense amount of variables in physical reality.
Consider a Riemann proof as text is a tiny amount of information relative to all the radiation and stuff floating in space or jiggle at the quantum scale.
Same with a neuralink + brain as our meat suits only want to make sense of things that are familiar.
Cosmic and quantum scale is way different than this stable middle ground we live in. We can still do a lot to stabilize here but I doubt things like space colonization work out given we cannot predict enough of the future to avoid the single catastrophic event that will end all progress and force a do over; Earth's resources can only support giving is so many mulligans. I see limited resources/time as another example of scaling laws just applied across eons.
Even though it's far more far fetched it's probably a better long term goal to focus on Stargate or The Expanse like gate technology rather than chew up Earth's resources chasing Star Trek ships.
You’ve taken the opportunity to glaze Amodei and now Musk in this unrelated thread. Perhaps we can celebrate the actual human researchers and doctors who made this advance.
You know BCI was a lively and progressing field before musk ever touched it, right?
And that BCIs have been used for people to play videogames literally since videogames were invented?
Neuralink is a refinement in the field, not a revolution.
edit: Watch the video shared in sibling comments. The big difference in neuralink from BCI SOTA in 1990 is a smaller set of hardware reading your brain (genuine improvement), configurability (minor improvement), and I think a significant improvement in fidelity. The implementation of thinking about moving a body part to give a reader a trivial muscle neural signal to read is older than I am, and has not improved as far as I can tell. That said, the user is demonstrating fine control of a game, so if those advancements were what it took to go from playing Civilization to playing GTA, kudos.
BCIs however are zero percent of the way towards anything like "scanning" your brain or "uploading" your brain, concepts that themselves might not even be physically possible. Even if you could magically copy your brain signals to a computer a la moving a VM, you would not be uploaded to the computer. A clone of your experience would. You still die in misery.
Unfortunately, the primary value Musk brought to the field was a willingness to invest money. Time and time again, his cultish supporters mistake a banal investment in engineering as groundbreaking, because they completely ignore the total lack of investment before he waved his cash around. We don't need musk to invest in things. We need a willingness to spend money towards goals. Also maybe read some magazines. BCIs were something Popular Science talked about occasionally, which is one of the ways I know about prior art in the field.
I suspect it will take far fewer of those experiments for AI to develop a good simulation model of the phenomena at work than it has historically takens for humans to be able to understand and characterize it. Anthropic is already working on this: they're building a wet lab where researchers will conduct Claude-designed experiments. It really is kinda like Aperture Science, which (for me) is a source of both awe and concern.
This is satire, right? We're in a thread that says "wow, for once no hyperbole" - which one cannot help but associate with the lack of AI references in the article - and here we are a few comments deep with breathless AI hyperbole. Complete with cult personality worship.
I can't tell anymore.
I understand it's hard to burn through an 8-figure marketing budget but this is wild.
AI is dancing and sparkling its way towards solutions we've struggled with for decades if not centuries. That's not hyperbole; it's the reality we're currently dealing with. It portends both unimaginable well-being for us all (or at least those who could still afford it) as well as a complete deflation of our sense of purpose besides merely existing and keeping the machine's data troughs fed.
The commonality on all of AI's huge accomplishments so far is fast feedback, immediately verifiably true (assuming you trust Lean) answers. It is very far from being able to make the claim that it can do the same in clinical research.
Are you referencing something like Riemann hypothesis, which it came out 6 hours later someone had already written a proof for with zero AI? I think AI is great and will have its use cases, but I think your drinking the kool-aid a bit too much.
The human-written proof is not verified and contains several errors, it's not unlikely that there is one that breaks the whole proof because this has happened plenty of times for Riemann.
Masullo's proof has severe flaws in it. The Claude proof has been mechanically checked and found to be valid (with respect to the produced Lean formalization).
Honestly with all the bad press, I'm still determined and hope for a better future where this becomes reality. I just hope the focus shifts towards that, it would be an incredible achievement.
Which cancer? I ask because the specific thing preventing “a cancer cure” is the fact that cancers are only vaguely related. It’s like saying “broken bone is a problem that can be solved.”
Yes, it can, but to imply it’s simply one disease is missing completely the exact reason why it’s so hard to cure.
RAS is a (class of) proteins in the membrane of your cells that are important in telling cells when it is time to grow. These proteins cycle between an "active" state that stimulates growth and an "inactive" state that doesn't. An extremely common genetic mutation that happens as a person develops cancer causes some of these cells to start making RAS proteins that do not correctly switch back to the "inactive" state. The cells with these mutations then grow and divide very rapidly and can become a tumor. Daraxonrasib works by binding the active state RAS proteins and preventing them from signalling and triggering growth. This can help prevent the tumors from growing further and potentially even shrink them as they are attacked by the immune system or other medication.
(I'm not an expert, just a fan of knowing how things work, anyone can correct me if they know better)
Yes, FOLFIRINOX is a combination of chemotherapeutic agents.
Which is very different from being administered an adenovirus (VRT106) that recognizes a receptor often expressed on cancer cells (MXRA8), that after ‘infecting’ the cell triggers direct oncolysis and indirect immunogenic responses.
“Last week, the former senator from Nebraska Ben Sasse announced that his Stage 4 pancreatic cancer had developed resistance to a cutting edge treatment.“
Irrelevant aside, but that's a nice garden path sentence. My brain threw a couple of exceptions trying to parse what a "therapy former senator" is before finally realizing it's "the therapy [...] Ben Sasse is taking".
Does the -ib medication suffix have meaning? I know -ab medications like Benralizumab, Canakinumab, etc are monoclonal antibodies. The only -ib I can remember other than this new one is Imatinib, which is also a cancer treatment, so maybe it's to do with cancer?
The suffix -ib stands for inhibitor, but it's
not a standalone suffix as such.
In this case the "real" suffix is -rasib, meaning RAS inhibitor. This is the "stem" defined by the WHO [1].
You have other suffixes like -coxib (for COX inhibitors like celecoxib) and -nib (for kinase inhibitors like upadacitinib, where -citinib then refers to JAK/TYK type kinase).
It’s a category called small-molecule drug. I take a medication called upadacitinib for ulcerative colitis. Previously, I took monoclonal antibodies called Ustekinumab and vedolizumab.
These medication-categories are not only prevalent in cancer therapy.
If you look at the molecular size, -ibs are very small and -mabs really huge.
I’m not in biotech so I don’t understand how approvals work, but it sounds like it’s already being used and that patients develop a resistance to it and it stops working. Perhaps someone in the field can help explain the dissonance between these articles.
There isn’t a dissonance. It can be both a breakthrough and just a first step. A median survival in the trial of 13 months means 50% of participants died in 13 months or less, which is simultaneously an exciting advance (in this disease, in 2L) and a tragedy.
The answer as to why is for ongoing investigation. Cancers are complex entities, and a single patient’s cancer may have multiple mechanisms capable of driving its growth. Daraxonrasib blocks several of these mechanisms, but in time, either some of the suppressed mechanisms escape its suppression, or other mechanisms which aren’t suppressed become more active and continue the growth.
But people need to keep in mind how much money there is in math proofs before they get too excited. In short: there's very little. Mathematicians are often regarded as a pinnacle of human intelligence, but most of them are working at universities and working on these problems in their off time.
There are a few exceptions, but they are very rare. Anthropic is apparently paying people to do this kind of work full time. They've also been also dumping orders of magnitude more money into these problems than we've spent in the past.
It's not like cancer research. Cancer isn't an equation that will be cured as soon as it's proven, and solving it isn't a hobby that a professor has to juggle with teaching duties. This is already a billion dollar research field that is data limited, subject to ethical considerations, and extremely complicated logistically.
AI can help with all that, but it won't be solved by forking Claude 15M worth of tokens.
On the other hand, it would be great if Anthropic wants to fork 15M worth of tokens the rare research software engineer who is struggling to integrate the 15 proprietary data formats their lab uses into a coherent database. Maybe they can help build a database that streamlines data sharing, or improves logistics to set up studies. There's a lot to hope for here!
AI is acting on perfect information in arenas like GRH and Chess.
The human body is not a game like chess. There is hidden information everywhere: stuff nobody ever tried to measure, stuff that somebody tried to measure and got it wrong, and the stuff people tried to measure and actually got right.
An AI can’t just deduce a prior hard physical facts about people.
And I’m pretty sure the stuff people measured correctly is a tiny fraction of all the features and data that are relevant to cancer in a human body.
Outsider to the domain, but I am hopeful that one day ML and classical techniques can be combined to simulate proteins and cells in-silico at many orders of magnitude speedup. We know the math, it’s just too slow to model it all today.
You cannot simulate a human. Not even in theory. There's no magic AI can find to overcome that.
There aren't enough atoms in the universe to even contain a theoretical computer able to do it.
The universe will always be dramatically faster at "running" atoms and interactions than a computer, because a computer will always have to explicitly do the work of summing up interactions with all other atoms and particles, something the universe itself gets "for free".
Part of the possible speedup from things like quantum computers is taking advantage of the fact that the universe will "run" a set of interactions faster and with higher fidelity than you ever could hope
What you can do, though, is develop abstract or ML models that approximate the behavior of some object. The model is designed to run thousands, millions, billions of times faster. You can benchmark this abstract model against the actual mathematical simulation for general correctness within error bars. Then you can use it.
I mean, that’s what happens in other domains that cross into intractability.
Maybe you're assuming the parent comment meant on the same timescale as GRH was solved.
Otherwise I feel the parent's comment is perfectly reasonable.
Cancer is simply a fatal combination of mutations that results in a set of cells that no longer follow the regulations in place that the organism uses to control unbounded and out of place growth of that or those cells.
I see no reason AI would be unable to help with such a simple problem statement.
In many ways cancer is simpler than the Riemann hypothesis to attack.
The complexity of cancer, from what I've studied, isn't that we don't understand what's broken about the cells. It's that we don't manipulate matter as efficiently as biology to attack those broken cells.
Just this week news hit about a virus that can stop pancreatic cancer in its tracks.
Now why can the virus do this and not our medicines?
Because viruses work on the same scale of matter manipulation and process genetic information at the same physical scale that our cells do.
You're right that the ability to emit tokens, no matter how intelligent, is tangential to our ability to manipulate matter.
However DNA and RNA can be expressed as tokens.
Thus one can imagine that just as AI has helped us emit information via language and code tokens faster, it ought to be able to emit DNA sequences faster than any human typing out A's, T's, C's and G's by hand.
Thus, I can imagine a world in which cancer cell sequencing happens much faster and viral targets for those cancer cells are written by AI as easily as they write code today.
That AIs have somehow managed to wrangle all human information to advance human capability in a variety of domains is promising because individual humans likely have no hope of wrangling, in a single human mind, all of the genetic, physical, and chemical pathways in a living organism as complex as a human.
I'm not predicting when this happens but given that there are already services that will print a custom DNA or RNA strand to order, I absolutely see a world in which viruses, custom-designed to attack an individual's cancer cells bearing genetic markers matching the cancer cell type (e.g breast, lung, etc.) and mutations should be possible since fundamentally biology is built on information (RNA and DNA).
So I agree with you that we shouldn't expect a "cancer cure" in the next 6 months.
But since cancer starts in the information-holding part of the cell, building therapies that are information-sensitive with a previously unimagined rapid turnaround, and packaged in a virus which may also be heavily genetically modified to suit this purpose, does seem like exactly the type of problem these new generative manipulators of information are built to solve.
> And I’m pretty sure the stuff people measured correctly is a tiny fraction of all the features and data that are relevant to cancer in a human body.
AI can now, or will soon be able to deduce:
* what additional data it needs to gather
* how to conduct measurements to gather that data
* once gathered, what the data portends in terms of the mechanism of action of cancer
* what course of treatment will kill the cancer with a minimum of interference with healthy body cells
All we would have to do is feed it enormous amounts of the right kind of information and it could come up with a treatment that will vastly ameliorate many kinds of cancers. Anthropic is already working on this; they have a wet lab where the biologists are "meat proxies" conducting experiments for Claude which is developing new drug candidates. This is already happening.
I'm realistic enough to understand that a total or near-total cure for pancreatic cancer won't happen tomorrow. But it will still be very soon compared to the time horizon typical of medical research, wherein progress happens very slowly over decades.
AI will, but the most important thing we need is directors to guide it, same as GRH
Right now AI can check images and give you accurate diagnosis. But that is something already there. We need to prevent, better than cure. And to prevent we need more info about the causes, we need more strict rules about environmental contamination, same as we did with smoking. We need to understand the influence of drugs, chemicals, food, stress, in the development of cancer. We need to put all knowledge in one place in order to allow specialists and geniuses to find solutions. Creating walled silos of knowledge is in benefit of none but a few, that's why open weights, open models, and open knowledge is extremely important for us all
I think the future will be better for those who prevent it, not just cure it. Accurate prevention will make us immune to cancer
I hope we see more progress on medicine with or without AI, personally.
I don't understand why you would believe developing a formal proof and developing a successful medical intervention share any relevant commonalities. They share neither problem structure nor solution space and require materially different forms of labor. Math is handy in that it is notably divorced from material and biological reality. Oncology notably less so.
My former boss, one of the nicest, kindest and most jovial guys I've ever known, had pancreatic cancer. He quite literally wasted away before our eyes and died within a year. He was a big, round guy in life, but lying in his casket, it was like someone had let all the air out of a balloon. There wasn't anything left of him.
Pancreatic cancer is nasty (most cancers are), but the recent breakthroughs make me hopeful that we'll one day see a world where it won't be so devastating.
Former PM of Czechia, Topolánek, suffers from pancreatic cancer and is very open about it in the media.
Accidentally I know him personally, we lived in the same city. A tough guy, though not an angel; anyway, politics aside, I am glad that he is still alive and that he did a huge job opening the debate on pancreatic cancer and its possible prevention or early treatment.
He is also a frequent guest in podcasts and I noticed lately that his face looks really weird, as if scalded. I believe this is a side-effect of daraxonrasib. He mentioned something about experimental treatment.
I don't know if you intentionally mentioned measles but as of a few days ago, we officially can't say measles "was" a thing (at least here in the U.S.)...
Really don't get this cynicism. And it's in every thread about this topic.
Once something like this have been invented, we (humanity) have them forever. Long after the patent for Rasonque expires in 14 more years and it sells for cost plus some margin. Lipitor was once the most profitable drug in the world and now my mother takes it for $4/month. For a cancer example, Keytruda is going off patent soon. We will have that incredible gift forever. The inventor repayment period (patent protection) only lasts a little while in the grand scheme.
Let me be clearer - this drug is expensive garbage. There are several cancer drugs that are currently being studied that appear to be orders of magnitude more effective for prostate cancer, without the severe side effects. Unfortunately for the pharmaceutical industry, they are no longer under patent so there is no $$ to be made.
Sorry what? Prostate cancer is one of the most survivable cancers (98% 5-year survival rate) and pancreatic cancer, which is what the post is about, is the lowest (13% 5-year survival rate). I think you got confused. This is a major breakthrough for pancreatic cancer. Nothing like this exists anywhere.
And your claim about off-patent treatments not being used because they can't make money is just simply incorrect. Trastuzumab, Oxaliplatin (used for pancreatic btw), Rituximab, Bevacizumab, and many other therapies are all examples of front-line cancer treatments in 2026 that are off-patent. A vial of Fluorouracil is like $8. It's the standard front-line treatment for Colorectal Cancer, prescribed in about 95% of metastatic cases.
Daraxonrasib is mostly about the common types of pancreatic cancer, mostly PDAC with KRAS mutations. Jobs had a PNET (Pancreatic neuroendocrine tumor) that typically doesn't have a KRAS mutation, and has a much better prognosis compared to the death sentence that PDAC is. But he shot himself in the foot by delaying his whipple procedure.
There's only one sure treatment for all types of cancers and that is gene repair. But pharmaceutical companies aren't interested because repairing genes cannot be patented. The future is being delayed because of corporate interests.
I think the layman's perception of the increase in survival (~13 months versus ~6 months) will make this look underwhelming. Nevertheless, it's important to remember that the incentives for clinical trials is to only include very late-stage patients who have exhausted all other options (faster trials, smaller sample sizes, surrogate endpoints, a shot at accelerated approval, ...). The fact that a treatment shows promise for these patients that are often in very poor health and considered "hopeless" by today's medicine is exceedingly rare, and the signal from this trial is indeed strong.
The (somewhat reasonable) hope is that patients 1. with earlier forms of pancreatic cancer (non-metastatic) 2. that can undergo surgery 3. together with a (neo)adjuvant treatment with these kras inhibitors, will end up having a much lower recurrence rate and a chance for a long, healthy life.
I think this is genuinely good news worth celebrating!
I have a friend who has a relatively good prognosis among pancreatic cancer patients but even still is facing the very real chance he won’t be here in 6 months. His wife gives birth to their second child in a month or so. I guarantee if it came down to it he would give literally anything to double his time with them.
I think many of us would give anything to double whatever lifespan we have remaining at almost any point. Sorry about your friend!
“Man! Because he sacrifices his health in order to make money. Then he sacrifices money to recuperate his health. And then he is so anxious about the future that he does not enjoy the present; the result being that he does not live in the present or the future; he lives as if he is never going to die, and then dies having never really lived.” - Tenzin Gyatso
Caveat: a lot of people sacrifice their health to give others - their spouses, children, relatives most often, but often eventually also neighbors and community - health, peace, safety, opportunities, moments of happiness, a better start. All of which is purchased with money.
Without understanding this dynamic, the toil indeed looks like an absurd paradox. But the paradox is not in the reality, just in one's simplistic assumptions.
The price of getting what you want, is getting what you once wanted.
I think stared learning that at 10. Still need regular reminders.
As it's HN it's better to be precise:
> Thank you for your email inquiring about this particular quote which has been attributed to His Holiness the Dalai Lama. His Holiness has made no such remarks, either in speech or in writing. We trust this clarifies it.[0]
[0] https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/660843-please-edit-or-c...
It’s true but what do you want people to do ? Not work and live in a monastery ?
Get a smaller house and a car that’s enough and don’t sell your soul to a boss who’s hoping the bonus he earns off of you misbehaving will buy his summer home.
Maybe read some Baudrillard. Most of our problems are made up and we chase analogs for what we actually want, and then we are made about it not being enough.
Lots of people are grinding just to make rent and have zero chance of ever owning a house, even a small one.
Lots of people doesn’t mean a high percentage. The 65.2% of Americans lived in a home owned by a member of that household in 2025, and significantly more people are able at some point to do so at some point in the future.
Meanwhile Lots of people are homeless or in prison…
America is the richest country in the world.
BTW, I think this high number is really small for such a rich country.
Wealth has little to do with home ownership rates.
America ranks well behind Mexico, India, Pakistan, China, and many other countries with far lower median incomes.
Americans are a tiny part of world population though.
America is fairly average in terms of home ownership rates. Slightly below Canada or Australia and well below Mexico, India, Pakistan, China, and many other far less affluent countries.
And part of that is greed by the owner. Tenzin isn’t talking about a straight line of individual decisions, or at least not only. We are affected by the odd priorities of everyone around us as well. The collective Man.
It's not just one or the other, surely
How about just have some awareness of the trap and not fall for the trap. The trap is in over spending, over consuming, over working. Find the middle way - and reject society who tells you to do otherwise.
Novelty seeking is very expensive when you let other people set the menu.
There’s a lot of stuff outside that’s still free or at least cheaper than a brand new SUV with heated back seats, and still counts as novel, or even informative.
monks worked
The important part is why you work, I think.
Monks work (present tense) so much that most of us would be whiny babies about doing a half shift of their work.
Genuinely curious what the day shift of a monk is, i knew one for a while but never thought to ask specifics.
They post their schedules!
Here is an example for Catholics: https://www.abbaye.ca/en/learning-about-the-abbey/monastic-l...
Scroll down to: "A day in a monk’s life" section.
It's basically work and prayers, from 4am to ~8pm.
Wake up early, prepare food, tend to the rice paddy, tend to the chicken coop, clean up, exercise, tend to the kitchen, read, pray, sleep. Often that ends up being a whole 14 hour day with not much time for anything else. Manual labor sucks.
I don't think that is the message. People do need to work and make money to support themselves and their families. But there are also lots of people who only focus on collecting more money to achieve some type of lifestyle at greater expenses then any dollar is worth.
My dad said to his doctor who was working 10 plus hours 6 or 7 days a week between 2 practices he owned "you don't want to end up the richest man in the cemetery". It triggered the doctor. He started explaining about how his kids were in college and he mortgage this bill and that bill. He was absolutely anxious and stressed despite making multiple times more then the average person. So I believe the underlying message is more about work life balance. Don't spend your life chasing money that will leave you empty in the end.
We also work for people who are like that when we could work someplace else. So we end up doing charity work for their get rich (or out of perpetual debt) story while missing special events with family.
There was a great commercial years ago of a guy in front of a spruced up but typical middle class house, on a riding lawnmower, talking about his three cars, boat, and vacations, and then he said, “I’m in debt up to my eyeballs, please help.”
I grew up lower middle class, upside down mortgage, struggle foods. I’m really good at doing without things until I can afford them, until there’s a sale, rather than buying them on credit and paying for them twice. That’s how you end up running down a hill, trying not to fall on your face.
What I’m not good at is convincing a partner they can do this too. That a smaller apartment or house but in the same area would give us more freedom without longer commutes in the bargain. The struggle is real but you lose the moment you just relent.
I truly wish you the best. I once lived like you. I grew up not once going hungry but I knew at an early age that my parents were far from rich. But that gave me an awareness of money and spending it wisely. For a short time I racked up a small debt in my early 20s not understanding how credit cards can cripple one once they get out of hand. I spend years in debt and always stressed and anxious. When I finally got out of debt it was a huge weight off my shoulders. I didn't realize before how much it was draining me until that point.
Since then I have been careful and like you don't want to use credit for no reason and instead save up for the things I want then use my credit cards to get the rewards and pay it off right away.
But I too had a time when married where I was highly conscientious about finances but my wife was the complete opposite. We were always broke because it was one thing after the next that she had to buy. A new couch or new bed or needed the latest phone and so on. I let it happen and didn't take control. When we later separated and I had full control of my financials I have never had more money. I am not a scrooge and spend money on things but I don't like to waste it. My advice to you is to find a way to set the rules and be assertive and not let her make the decisions. You are the one being financially responsible so don't let her pressure you into bad choices.
Don't take loans unless it funds a higher cash flow than the interest incurred. The only exceptions are emergencies.
The key is to hold off spending on things that you don't care a lot about. What I wear is mostly decades old. I buy new shoes when the current ones become unusable or too uncomfortable. I stay away from brands for the most part.
Most people would think that I live a miserly existence because my spends are not externally visible when I meet them.
But there are gifts. It allows for a bigger budget for travelling / hiking in the woods and the mountains. More budget for live blues bands that I love listening to but almost no one has heard of. More budget for second hand books and for buying supplies for hand made crafts.
Clarity over what gives one joy is gold.
Only thing is that I am an incorrigible ADHD afflicted hobby hopper. But over time I cycle back. All in all not too bad.
>What I’m not good at is convincing a partner they can do this too... The struggle is real but you lose the moment you just relent.
Sounds like you are very bad at picking partners who have compatible values as you.
“It's easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism.”
I paste this Mark Fisher quotation far too often here but it’s one of those “if even one person hears it click” deals.
I'm really tired of hearing all these simplistic "capitalism bad!" tropes. Rampant greed can ruin any system. And I never see the tropes followed up by an actually competent discussion of what we should do instead, especially if we want to preserve basic individual economic freedom. I feel what we need are working checks and balances and a culture that is less focused on flashing around personal wealth, not radical revolution that tries to bring on a kind of soviet union 2.0 or ... "something" that is somehow magically great.
As another responder said, we all get sucked into that greed too and we compromise ourselves and our safety to chase it.
When the chase ends you don’t recognize where you are.
That part is voluntary. I'm somewhat vehemently against consumerism as well as big business, but equally strongly in favor of capitalism. The main reason is liberty. If one thinks that e.g. communism is a good path forward then you're 100% free to try to create your communist utopia within a capitalist system. You don't really need much money to buy some land in the middle of nowhere to start your commune with some like-minded individuals. As an added benefit you'd even get a 100% free trade agreement with the US, for free.
But imagine the situation were reversed and we were in a communist system. Try to go start your own little capitalist utopia and it's off to the gulags with you. Perhaps that's hyperbolic, but not by much - you are required to play a role from the state in a communist system. And so if you happen to try it out and find it's not for you - there is simply no escape. This is where the old USSR jokes come in, like 'What do you call a Soviet quartet that's allowed to play abroad?' 'A duet.'
It’s not exactly “not being capitalist” to say “well you just need to buy the resources to not need the rest of society, or have enough money to trade for them!”
On a macro level you're right, but my reading of what they meant was more on a personal level, in the vain of "you're free to do your own thing". Start a commune if that is what works for you. Grab some like-minded people and have it your way. I'm from Germany, and if you tried to "have it your way" in, for example, the GDR, you'd be in Bautzen in no time. The GDR inherited Bautzen straight from the 3rd. Reich. I'm not saying every alternative to capitalism needs to end up this way. But I'm tired of hearing "capitalism bad" like we could just simply decide to "do something better". We tried, it ended just as horribly as fascism. The freedom to conduct our lives how we see fit necessarily includes (personal!) freedom of profession, freedom to trade and things like that.
People really need to watch the news broadcasts from '89, when the wall came down. I was only 10 at the time, and my family did not have any friends or family in eastern Germany, but thinking about it still moves me. The endless happiness of the people that their prison time has ended.
Footage of the wall coming down never fails to make my eyes well up.
What land would the commune sit on and how would it pay taxes
Same as any country or the countless communes throughout the US. Any society needs to make things. If you're not completely self sustaining then you export some of that and then import what you need to sustain yourselves. This is why I mentioned having a free trade agreement with the US already. You get to import/export whatever you create to one of the largest consumer markets in the world - for free. That's a valuable perk for free.
And in reality you don't really need to entirely disconnect from the capitalist world if you don't want. At least some people could maintain normal jobs, ideally remote, pool their resources, select a governing body to manage those funds, and go from there. This isn't like one of those mocking things - there are already many communes in the US, though none have managed to grow to a particularly large scale. But there's nothing stopping more people from trying it.
---
As for the land itself - there's lots of land available in the middle of nowhere for dirt cheap. Some of it's even freely available if you agree to build a house on it.
There are always reasons it's cheap or free. Usually pertaining to obligations the capitalist system put on it, or the land itself is complete crap.
It's because most people prefer to live where there's a ton of businesses and consequently people within a stone's throw. Better job opportunities, entertainment, etc. All that then jacks local prices on everything, especially land, up to insane levels. If you're willing to live outside consumerville then prices on everything, again - especially land, exponentially decline.
You're probably thinking of free markets. Free markets are where the economy is free (it's in the name). Capitalism is where the economy is controlled by whoever has the most capital. Capitalists spend a fair amount of money trying to tell you that capitalism is a free market, it isn't.
Unchecked capitalism is in fact really bad, and the US's politics are so far right compared to anywhere in Europe that people yelling "capitalism bad" are hardly in danger of setting off a communist revolution. They might, if they're lucky, make someone think "huh yeah we maybe could tax billionaires a bit more without crashing the world economy."
So you just read the source and disagreed with the premise? I post this because the site is haunted by people saying they would never join a union because they’re three best developer ever and it would suppress their wages. At no point do they ever consider serious injury or health issues, falling in love and having kids, etc. having said that,
> preserve basic individual economic freedom
Where do you live where you have this? Because I trudge along in the United States well aware I do not have this in spite of making like $200k.
What source? I reacted purely to the quote you posted.
I live in Europe, make significantly less than you and feel like money isn't that big of a factor in my personal happiness. Sure, more would be kinda nice. But I'm mostly content with what I have.
But I meant "economic freedom" not in the sense of "I feel like I can do whatever I want because money isn't a factor", more in the sense of "there is no system in place that prevents me or my fellow countrymen from taking up this or that profession or even inventing a new profession" (for example). More in the vain of free speech, the freedom to make a living how I see fit.
That's almost nothing to do with capitalism
But is has to do with how alternatives to capitalism might look like. They would, in my opinion, need to have certain characteristics. So far, I've yet to see a good one with respect to the characteristics I care about.
> Where do you live where you have this? Because I trudge along in the United States well aware I do not have this in spite of making like $200k.
Not the person you asked, but IMO $200k is an insane amount of money. I live in the US, was making a bit less than that (checked, inflation adjusted) and we raised a family with two kids and paid for their colleges while living a very comfortable life.
Both of us are immigrants of 30+ years and both are very frugal, so standards for "very comfortable" might be lower than what US kids today expect, but still. Not a criticism, but curious -- where do you feel $200k is not enough? I know SF and NYC are insanely expensive, but that is not the whole of the US. My 2c.
It feels like it would be better to determine what each of this “basic economic freedom” might be. I also wonder if your perspective is different based on being (it sounds) older than me. We are not living hand to mouth or one paycheck away from disaster, but I would say we are in what little remains of a middle class in the US. We have socked away a fair bit of money for our daughter’s college years, but not enough and we have socked away plenty of money for retirement but that particular goalpost keeps drifting further into the future. Our cars are paid off and not flashy, we aren’t spending on frivolities (at least imo). But we are working to stay alive and not a ton else.
Thank god what we have is crony capitalism and one can imagine the end of crony capitalism.
What would non-crony economy-controlled-by-the-biggest-capital-holders look like? Seems like an oxymoron
Pretty offensive. Cancer doesn’t care about karma or dogma.
The thing with Buddhism is the notion that many of our injuries are self inflicted or even conjured out of nowhere, and you just exhibited a top shelf example of that.
What I quoted has absolutely nothing to do with karma, and everything to do with how scared you are of dying with regrets. I understand the people who want to see their kid graduate. But just in general principle? Fighting for two more months when even more of that time will be in agony than if you did nothing, and spending your kids inheritance to do that? Why do we do that to ourselves? And why do we sign them up to watch? You can sort out your conflicts with your friends and family in a week, or you can’t sort them out at all. Car wrecks and heart attacks take even that away. At least a terminal illness gives you a last call.
Cancer is cruel. Cancer treatment is only less cruel, and still cruel enough that people volunteer to work in cancer wards to make the patients a little more comfortable (my ex signed up for one but couldn’t follow through).
“Time” is not a reason to stay. It’s a placeholder for magic thinking or something you don’t want to face. And when someone asks YOU what you want to have before you die, you’d better have an answer or you’ll waste it. “Time” is the answer you give when you don’t know the answer and you’re hoping you’ll think of it later. By the time you’re fifty you’ll already know that’s bullshit, or you’ll be buried having never suspected.
> everything to do with how scared you are of dying with regrets.
That's not the part of the quote people are objecting to. The biggest issue is the "sacrificing health to make money" part. Almost all jobs are not a significant strain on health. And a typical person isn't too anxious to enjoy themselves either.
Could also be interpreted as sacrificing your healthiest years
“Almost all jobs”? Do you really believe that the overwhelming majority of jobs keep you safe from environmental and industrial pollution? Nevermind stress->inflammation->cancer pathways.
> Do you really believe that the overwhelming majority of jobs keep you safe from environmental and industrial pollution?
Your home and the places you visit outside work are also polluted. The threshold here isn't for almost all jobs to protect you, it's for almost all jobs to not make your exposure significantly worse.
> Nevermind stress->inflammation->cancer pathways.
Among all the other cancer pathways, and lots of stress isn't job-related.
Says who?
But it "cares" how you live. How much and how well you sleep, how much stress you feel every day. If you take the time to eat well etc. etc
It's pretty useless to talk about "cancer" as one thing. Many cancers do not "care" whatsoever about any of that. Even among the ones that do, I would be careful not to imply you can know anything new about a person by finding out they have a specific type of cancer. For one, it's almost always a statistically unwarranted leap, and second (more importantly), it makes you sound like a monstrous asshole.
Yes, cancer is complex. But in general it seems well established, that way of living does influence chances of getting some cancer. Apart from that, no concrete judgements were made.
And the "monstrous" post above was not at all about that, but about "sacrificing health for money, then sacrificing money for health, but never finding peace in the now".
General life advice. No one said as a general statement, "if you have cancer, it is your fault".
There are also people who see the protocol and hear the prognosis and say, you know, I’ve had a good life. How comfortable can you make me for the four months I have? And sometimes it’s six, or two years. I just heard of one that was three weeks.
It’s easier to accept when your bucket list is pretty checked off. And particularly if your kids are doing okay.
> Because he sacrifices his health in order to make money.
Yeah, no. People don't get pancreatic cancer because of this.
Blaming people for being victims of this terrible disease is offensive. Not that you did it directly, but it's still pretty much what this quote means.
That wasn’t…
That’s not a good-faith interpretation of the comment to which you’re replying. Drop the “offense” because it’s a hammer looking for a nail.
That's not what the this quote means.
The quote isn't blaming individuals, but humanity as a group. We have created an economic system that has polluted large portions of the planet and that has brought us to the brink of ecological collapse, and these collective actions have both created many of the diseases that we suffer from and the cures for them.
>these collective actions have both created many of the diseases that we suffer from
Okay, but cancer isn’t one of them. The Edwin Smith papyrus demonstrates that human beings have been dealing with it for literally millennia. And at the time that surgical treatise was written, there were no cures.
Cancer certainly existed prior to modern times. However this source[0] indicates that at least 42% of American cancer cases are attributable modifiable risk factors.
With that said, you're missing the point of the quote and my explanation. Slow down and take some time to think about it.
[0] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29160902/
Additionally, we collectively hate bad news, so we procrastinate, even though we all know that early detection improves outcomes considerably. It’s easier to let the friction of the medical system convince us we can just do this later. There’s plenty of time later to do it.
If it's not blaming individuals, then it's crap writing. What does "he" mean, except for an individual? You seem to be adding meaning far beyond what was actually written.
As someone with plenty of chronic illnesses, I know how easy it is to cast blame, but, I've found, it's an extremely useless activity, and almost never productive.
In response to a discussion about pancreatic cancer, the quote was: "he sacrifices his health in order to make money."
If that's not casting blame on an individual, then WTF?
> I know how easy it is to cast blame, but, I've found, it's an extremely useless activity
Hang in there. My take on casting blame is that it makes some people feel less anxious about a capricious universe where some very bad outcomes hang on the cast of a die.
We have to take factors into account in order to limit the probability of negative happenstances, but the sad fact is that some people feel safer when they look at a homeless person, victim of crime, or a cancer patient and they think: this won't be me for X reason (I don't do dugs/walk alone at night/eat "chemicals").
It is a small step from that to go into a mentality of "he had it coming".
There is a conversational habit that many people have, of responding to a specific situation described by someone, with a generalization of that situation, or by bringing up one of their own similar experiences.
None of these responses are terrible, these responses are no doubt true. But in conversation, those are low bars.
These segues come across, and frankly are, very dismissive of the original particular circumstances brought up.
It is best to respond to specific situations, with something thoughtful and specific to them. The specific situation was not brought up as conversation filler or general smalltalk initiation, but for its specific import, so respect that.
Its an easy bad habit to have, but once it is recognized, it is fairly easy to break. And the result is people will find conversations with you much more thoughtful, caring, and pertinent.
Need examples beyond your own? Don't respond to the news that someone lost a leg with amputation statistics, or the time you almost lost a finger. Don't respond to someone's pain with trivia or tautology. Respond with specific comfort or help, or not at all.
I was one of these people- a few years ago I saw a video that showed people in "conversational stealing the moment" situations, and it became very (and embarrassingly) clear how I was probably making others feel. As you say, it was easy to adjust, though I still catch myself with the urge to jump in.
Could you please provide with a link to said video?
If I may pick a nit: I find that, in some cases, when a person shares an analogous story ("you lost a limb? Oh me too!"), it can very well be a sign of that person working to relate someone else's experiences to their own — empathy, basically. Not to be frowned upon.
It depends on the nuances of the interaction and, as we all know, text is pretty bad at getting across such nuance.
I'm not saying I mind your (just a pinch gatekeepy?) comment, but you know, there's lots of people out there, with different communication styles, and I feel it's generally good to assume the best of others' intentions.
That said, I do agree with the general "pay attention to how your words might be received" gist of what you're saying. Non-sarcastic smiley face (:
> If I may pick a nit: I find that, in some cases, when a person shares an analogous story ("you lost a limb? Oh me too!"), it can very well be a sign of that person working to relate someone else's experiences to their own
I agree that the motive is often a good one. An genuine attempt to connect.
But it is often perceived as making someone else's situation about oneself.
A bad habit like this one, doesn't need to come from a bad place. Just a lack of perspective. And it isn't a "hard" rule, but 99% of the time, if you keep the conversation on the other person's viewpoint, it is felt as support, instead of obliviousness or self-absorption. (Regardless of good motives.)
I would normally contentedly leave the thread there, but since you seem interested in such things, and since you have been generous sharing your background in another comment, I just want to put this idea to you:
I wonder if you have been (just slightly) repeating the same mistake, in a different way. I see you use words like "bad" and "good" on this topic; clearly you feel that some behaviors here are right and others are wrong. From your other comment, this seems to stem from your desire to avoid repeating your own previous mistakes. Maybe you wince at the accidental harm you caused in the past. And now that you have learned a lesson, you are trying to teach it to others. Good intentions (:
But I think that when you use a good/bad, right/wrong style of communication, it produces an unnecessarily adversarial tone, which can turn some people off to your otherwise nice advice. A "bad habit," as you might say.
In the past, it was:
Now, it is: Now, I don't know you. Maybe you really have interviewed a representative sample of humanity and verified your "99%" statistic. Maybe you really are in a position to judge right/wrong. But my sense is: probably you are extrapolating from your own limited experience.So, in a similar vein to the advice you gave, I'm suggesting: maybe it would be more successful for you to simply share your knowledge based on your personal experience, rather than trying to generalize and map it to abstract concepts of right and wrong. Keep it specific and humble.
To be even more specific: rather than "I see you doing X. That is a bad habit and causes harm. Here is a better way to act ..." try something like "I see you doing X. I've had trouble with that in the past, causing accidental harm. Maybe consider this other way ... "
But of course, what I'm suggesting would be mealy-mouthed and milquetoast to some. Some people like to give more pointed, judgmental-sounding advice, and they would rather receive it, too! Less beating around the bush, and all that.
So, I don't know the right answer. I just wanted to put this alternative in front of you for your consideration. I think the reason I replied to your original comment was in large part because you said "These segues come across, and frankly are, very dismissive ..." and I read that as an unnecessarily harsh and judgemental thing to say, despite your generally reasonable advice, and your certainly good intentions.
But anyway, I have enjoyed this interaction with you — clearly you care about other people, and your effect on them. I think our souls are similar, here (:
(Hopefully it is clear that my spiel above is very small peanuts and nuance-upon-nuance; I don't mean it to sound berating. Just offering another tool for you toolbox.)
This is a very interesting thought. Would you mind sharing a hypothetical (or real - perhaps from your own experiences) example?
Every conversation I ever had where someone brought up an incident that had serious meaning to them, and I immediately and habitually brought up a comparable one of my own. Or worse, a similar situation I had heard of. Thinking I was saying "I understand", when what gets perceived is "The situation that is bothering them involves nothing unique or worthy of my focused attention". Hundreds of such conversations at least.
As a sibling commenter points out, the motive is often a genuine attempt to connect. It just happens to be inept.
My point isn't to shame. But to avoid the negative impact, or lost positive impact, due to missed nuance.
Someone had to point out this common communication misfire to me too.
When someone is sharing something, connecting and demonstrating understanding is much more successful by showing you are focused on what they said, and their situation, not a generalization or free associated version of it. And especially not turning things toward oneself or some abstract other.
Creative people can almost always think of something comparable in some way, that they experienced. But did we really need to talk about that? Obviously not, since we had to be prompted. But the person whose situation prompted us felt the need to bring up their situation. Put their expressed need first.
They are sharing a need to talk about something serious and specific.
When someone is sharing anything painful, this is especially true.
I am not saying never bring up one's own experience. Once the dynamic is recognized, its usually easy to tell the difference between someone sharing something serious, vs. just chatting about something. And the difference between a "me too" reflex vs. sharing an experience that offers some genuine insight or help. Even then, staying focused on their experience will be appreciated as care and attention given.
--
Specific example, made up but typical:
When someone says "My mother died", the best response isn't "that's tough, I lost my mom too", or "that's bad, and it happens to all of us", it is "I am so sorry, were you close? Tell me about her." They brought up their mom, their loss. Show you care by keeping your focus on their mom and their loss. Encouraging them to share as much as they need to.
Their mom was a special person. Not an example mom or "like" another mom, just because other people have lost moms.
There is no "comparable" mom or loss, and even an inadvertent implication along those lines is inaccurate, insensitive. and tends to shutdown that line of conversation prematurely.
"I guarantee if it came down to it he would give literally anything to double his time with them."
I'm deeply sorry about your friend, but I guarantee that this is not true. Nobody will give 'literally anything'. All his money? His house? His children's health?
Of course not. There is always a tradeoff in any treatment. My wife has chosen to stop the treatment that may have given her a few more months because those months would have been spent with the permanent side-effects of that treatment - nerve damage in this case. She would have no longer been able to paint, or cook, or enjoy what time she has left to her.
I would give up all my money and my house to double my remaining lifespan.
I don't have children and if I did I wouldn't give to their health, but that's a matter of trading several lifespans for one, it's a bad trade no matter how much you value a lifespan compared to other things.
When a family has a pancreatic cancer diagnosis and they have to get all things in order in a hurry, the difference between 6 months and 13 months is immense.
Maybe I'm being clueless, but surely if the median survival time goes from 6 months to 13 months, the most likely way for that to happen would also be for a higher percentage of people to survive indefinitely - say, beyond five years? It would be weird if we had this existing life expectancy distribution with the median of the distribution at 6 months, and the pill pushed a ton of distribution mass to get the median to 13 months, and it somehow did that without getting more people to 2 years, 5 years, 10 years, ...
> surely if the median survival time goes from 6 months to 13 months, the most likely way for that to happen would also be for a higher percentage of people to survive indefinitely - say, beyond five years?
There's no way to know, unfortunately, but the trial data suggests otherwise [1]. This story is about anecdotes, and you should basically ignore it.
The trial for daraxonrasib was 16 months, with a median follow-up of 8.5 months, and the median progression-free survival in that trial was around 7 months. From this data alone, you can't really say anything about longer-term survival, but most patients appear to relapse well before 5 years.
Of course, that's still a benefit for a cancer where there's essentially no other options.
[1] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2605555
Thanks for the link. Phase 3 trial with 500 patients, and a lot of additional info not in the guardian article
most of these phase iii cancer treatment studies look at median overall survival and usually it's an underwhelming single digit increase in months of life extension with varying quality of life.
it's a hard problem, sure, but i still think there should be endpoints that measure total remission or durable halt of progression and that words like "breakthrough" should be reserved for when those endpoints are met.
Generally agreed, but pancreatic cancer is so brutal and rare that basically anything that has a hint of efficacy is welcome.
sure, but i looked into this a bunch for mcrpc sometime back and it was the same thing. i suspect once it metastasizes it's pretty much the same story, there are a couple of hacks that can slow it down for a few months, but nothing really stops it.
i often wonder if a fundamentally new approach is needed. rather than static compounds and long drug trials, some sort of mechanism for establishing some safety properties rapidly and on demand (in vitro?) and then something that looks more like closed loop high frequency monitor and adjust customized interventional therapies that are synthesized and customized on the molecular level.
the mrna dream, but actually doing it, probably with ai and in vitro safety testing, probably.
Since many treatments are on an asymptotic curve where the x-axis is how early the cancer was detected, I am sure that the usual hope when looking at one end of the curve is that it projects back in time with something approximating the other protocols that already exist.
Of course the fact that every curve is different is why every patient needs a consultation to decide if surgery, radiation, or chemo are your first stop. Because for people in this range of progression, surgery is less dangerous than chemo. And perhaps radiation to shrink the tumor first will make the tumor operable, which it currently isn’t because of what it’s right next to.
Or if it’s metastatic, maybe all three for different tumors. Excise this lymph node, radiation for the brain, etc.
An it's really important to note that the trend is important too where this is the worst it will ever be.
For someone who's life expectancy after x time doubles, it also means there's more time for more treatments or innovations in treatments because of the time increase.
From what I understand many cancer patients annd particularly their families are fairly attentive to treatments that are currently in late phase trails.
Unfortunately the problem is somewhat a Devil You Know. We know the consequences and the odds of old treatments, the new ones we don’t even know all of the consequences. So it’s easier to think of them as a miracle.
Of course old and frail people tend to die when they lose hope, so the placebo effect of something on the horizon, from a new treatment to your youngest’s graduation, is important.
My grandfather died of pancreatic cancer when I was two years old. If he had had another seven months, I might have little fragments of memories of him.
As a layman, more than double life expectancy is laudable.
> I think the layman's perception of the increase in survival (~13 months versus ~6 months) will make this look underwhelming. Nevertheless, it's important to remember that the incentives for clinical trials is to only include very late-stage patients who have exhausted all other options (faster trials, smaller sample sizes, surrogate endpoints, a shot at accelerated approval, ...).
I think your perception of perception is irrelevant and wrong.
I hope that the surgery, called Whipple surgery, could be skipped entirely one day, if the tumor can be overwhelmed with therapy.
The surgery is radical and the patient's quality of life goes permanently down.
A wisdom I am forever thankful that was repeatedly ingrained in me was the importance of time. So many of my elderly clients constantly said no matter what spend as much time as possible with my kids as they were young. And I did.
Several years back my niece was diagnosed with brain cancer at like 10-11 years old. She died at the age of 12. It crushed me. I couldn't imagine how my cousin could carry on but she had other kids that needed her. I am certain she would give everything she owns for another hour with her baby.
Even if this medication only gives you a couple extra minutes for me I would consider it priceless. I would be sad to learn if the average layman actually considered and extra 7 months as underwhelming.
No one's interested in longer survival rates (except maybe patients). What people want is a CURE.
The majority of people who get pancreatic cancer are relatively old. As someone pushing 60, I've probably got 20 years left, if something doesn't get me first. There's no cure for that! As you get older your perspectives change. I've accepted my remaining time is limited, but I'll take what I can get. I can guarantee you I'd be very happy for a longer survival rate if I had cancer right now - even a year is a significant fraction of my expected remaining life.
I also think this is great news, but I am also curious as to the side effects. When Ben Sasse was interviewed a few months ago while taking this drug, he had lots of bloody wounds and scars on his face which he said was a side effect of the drug.
That said, the drug reduced his tumor volume by 76% and he said it really improved his quality of life, so it still definitely sounds like great news, but I'm just wondering if the drug caused that many visible side effects if there are internal side effects that would wear down the body over time.
This is really big deal because pancreatic cancer’s low survival rate is due in large part to how late it’s often noticed. Is’s very difficult to spot it early, as there may be no symptoms.
My father died of pancreatic cancer. Well actually he died from the chemo thatw as treating his cancer. They said it would give him a year vs sic months but he died in a month. So I would say this would have been a better option.
Saying that, is it better to live longer knowing you are going to die just a little later? I would just advise people to prepare now for the idea of your death. Memento mori...
But the science, this is a RAS inhibitor which stops GTP from binding to the RAS enzymes which basically slows cell division. Many gene polymorphisms that sloe down RAS activity lead to these cells that are mutated to create higher RAS activity. (I think this is important.)
The GTP is also important before you get the cancer since low GTP will inhibit DNA repair.
https://aacrjournals.org/cancerdiscovery/article-abstract/14...
> is it better to live longer knowing you are going to die just a little later?
When deciding what to do today, we all know we have a limited number of days left and should not waste them. Sure 50 years is more than 6 months, but it doesn't change the fact that wasting time is a silly idea for everyone.
It is a big mystery to me why people are so bad at choosing what to do with their time compared to their stated goals. Nobody says "next weekend I plan to binge watch netflix and not get out of bed", yet many do exactly that.
yet both people will end up in the same place, there’s no good or bad way to spend your time
I couldn’t disagree more! Doing a bad thing is a bad way to spend time by definition; therefore “no bad way to spend your time” suggests there are no bad actions.
History is replete with truly abhorrent counterexamples. One can certainly spend time badly.
If nobody had ever created a computer virus we’d be far less prepared for people to start writing them.
As such even ‘abhorrent’ uses of one’s time can have long term positive outcomes. Which means we don’t have enough information to actually rank outcomes only heuristics.
> * It is a big mystery to me why people are so bad at choosing what to do with their time compared to their stated goals*
Sounds like you're really good at this. Use that gift and you will go far!
Modern medicine has ensured that a greater portion of our voter base has dementia. Cancer's victims are 90% the elderly. The leadership they choose leads to more deaths around the world than curing cancer saves.
For once, this isn’t hyperbole. Metastatic pancreatic cancer hasn’t had a meaningful new treatment in literally decades - it’s been brutal chemotherapy or slightly less brutal chemotherapy.
The new generation of KRAS inhibitors, of which daraxonrasib is just the first to make it to approval, is genuinely a practice-changing breakthrough.
It won’t cure people with metastatic disease, but it will help a lot live better lives for longer.
>Metastatic pancreatic cancer hasn’t had a meaningful new treatment in literally decades
Not true. The folfirinox chemo regimen was invented a couple of years ago, and it significantly increased the life expectancy and quality of life for terminal pancreatic cancer patients.[0]
[0]https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMoa1011923
FOLFIRINOX was first used in Pancreatic Ca before the millennium, and the paper you linked to (which proved the benefit in a proper phase 3 trial) was published in 2011 - so >1.5 decades ago.
“it significantly increased the life expectancy”
True. statistically it was significant.
Progression-free survival increased from 3 months to 6 months. (overall-survival increased from 7 months to 11 months).
Both statistically significant, and at the cost of increased toxicity during those additional 3 to 4 months of “’significantly’ increased life expectancy”
I don’t get why this is down-voted.
To decide whether a survival of 3 to 4 months in exchange for increased toxicity (decreased quality of life during those few remaining months)
is “significant” is a very nuanced decision between the patient and their physician.
Downvoted for mentioning that the life expectancy for metastatic pancreatic cancer was recently doubled. Apparently this new drug can't just be an advance, it has to be unprecedented, unique, and of course worth any price.
Brutal surgery too like the Whipple procedure. My sister's lasted 13 some hours and it probably gave her another year+ of life.
> For once, this isn’t hyperbole.
Am I missing something?
From other sources:
> Median overall survival: 13.2 months versus about 6.6 to 6.7 months with chemotherapy.
This is absolutely NOT hyperbole, this has been an intractable disease for deacades, and the very first trial to show improvement is a lower bound on how effective the drug will be, not a full estimate.
First, this is a brutal drug, very hard to tolerate, and as better ways are found to manage side effects and to dial in the dosing, the treatment effects will increase.
Further, this is in metastatic pancreatic cancer, a stage of the disease where virtually all hope of a cure is gone for most. Any progress here will translate into bigger gains in earlier stages of the disease. We test new unproven therapies in metastatic cases like these because all other better options have been exhausted. And for decades, all those trials have been failures, this is the first time something has worked at all.
Additionally, this is just the first drug showing how to go after KRAS. Follow-on drugs, which some people call mere "me-too" drugs, will improve efficacy, have fewer side effects, and be more tolerable, all improving real-world results.
And as we learn to make KRAS treatments more tolerable, we'll also learn about how best to combine them with other existing chemotherapies, which requires lots of testing. Go to ASCO, and you'll see trial after trial after trial of small variations, trying to continuously improve existing treatments. It's a slow and brutal way to learn, but it's all we've got.
So if you only look at 13.2 months versus 6.7 months, yes, you are missing something! This is like discovering a whole new vein of gold ore to mine. We don't know where it will lead or how big it is, but what we can see right now is far far more than 13.2 / 6.7.
Doubling life expectancy on a form of cancer infamous as a death sentence.
> Doubling life expectancy on a form of cancer infamous as a death sentence.
Would you say the same thing if it were doubled from five minutes to ten minutes? Who cares about doubling? It's the 7.5 months that's the point. And 7.5 months is what it is.
I'm sure whoever has it would be grateful for every extra day, and so would their family. I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish by writing this comment, but you just seem pedantic.
Knowing you are going to die in six months puts a huge toll on the family and the patient. I do not know if four more months of this toll would be worth it after seeing what my father went through in his one month of knowing this.
More time means more chances for people to travel, to see family who is stuck because of life circumstances, to make it to a wedding that you wouldn't've if you only had 6 months.
If all of you guys are fine with giving up those last few months, then give it to me and the others who want to soak up every last moment of life.
YMMV!
Sorry to hear about your father. I lost both my parents and an uncle to cancer, and am a survivor myself. So I speak from experience.
Extra months (quality of life aside) buys time while treatment research continues at an accelerating pace. Also, I haven't seen the distribution curve but the _median_ increasing by several months implies a small effect for some individuals but possibly multiple years for others. It's a big f'ing deal.
I already know that I will die in x months at most.
X is fairly large for now for me but...
If you find a medical condition where the actual prognosis is death in five minutes, and some treatment doubles it to ten, then yes that's a big deal.
Pessimizer, you are indeed a pessimizer.
Clinical medicine works with averages, but the outliers matter, because they are literal human lives.
There will be patients who won't even see that doubling, but there may also be patients who will go into permanent remission because of this drug. And we may study them, discover the reason why they respond so well, and try new approaches based on those discoveries.
BTW 5 vs 10 minutes is a non-trivial difference in emergency medicine. An easily deployable treatment that would prolong survival of brain cells in hypoxic conditions from 5 to 10 minutes would matter a lot when bringing critical patients into hospitals. So, your example of absurdity may well be non-absurd in certain real world context.
yeah 13 months still a death sentence. people on death row can wait 13 + years...
I don't see that as a breakthrough.
Merely counting months does not do much - you'd have to count the quality of these months too.
Often pancreatic cancer is discovered only after it has spread. If this can treat it at that point it turns the disease from a death sentence to a lifeline until more research can come to fruition
Exactly. Look around at the world we have today; a lot can happen in 6-7 more months.
If you'd taken that view on battery capacity you'd be happy with a smart phone that weighs as much as a brick and lasted 20 minutes fully charged.
I played with RC cars back in the 90s, 1200mAh was considered beefy before NiMh came and bumped it up slightly. Now we have lithium batteries with several times that capacity in the same form factor.
Most of that came from chipping away at it. Yes new technology got introduced but in the beginning they were not decisively superior, they had to be refined and improved little at a time.
Perhaps we'll find a miracle cure that fixes everything, maybe we have to chip away at it and get half a year here, another year there.
An effect that large is a medical breakthrough regardless of your opinion of the treatment impact.
Our lives are short anyway. You might as well be saying none of it is worth it.
If I had a choice between an average of 6 or 13 months, I'll take the 13.
And who knows, maybe they can refine the approach or improve screening for earlier detection or something and get it higher for future patients. This could be just the beginning.
I have a close relative currently in the last stage of a different type of cancer, would be pretty happy to extend their life by another six months. Or even better, improve quality of life because what I'm seeing is no life at all. This might or might not be a breakthrough by some strict definitions of the term, but sure is for those for whom it is important.
Those extra months, even if their quality is bad, are very meaningful for everyone close to someone that is leaving very soon.
Breakthroughs can be incremental and still have an impact. A little bit at a time eventually leads to a great things. It also speaks as to how hard the challenge is. We tend to appreciate things more when they are limited. That's true for the days in our lives too. Any amount of time is great and it's greatly appreciated.
Quality of life on chemotherapy is not great. Sadly, I know this firsthand through my father. I hope it gets approved in my country in time to reach him, even if it only gives him another year and a half.
For the low price of 40k a month, and you still get the same death sentence
We're all sentenced to death, but I'll still take the stay of execution.
That math gets more complicated to the degree the expense is shared with others, whether through insurance or public services.
The math is simple. The morality is what gets complicated.
It's very important to make sure the kids are left with nothing.
edit: If you asked me if I would like to live 7 more painful months for $40K/month, I'd at first think you were joking, and then I'd think you were insane. Of course not. Give 14 kids a full scholarship in my name.
We're putting a lot of effort into making sure that people leave this world completely drained of every penny.
You do you bro, I’m going out kicking and screaming.
Do not go gentle into that good night, Rage, rage against the dying of the light
It is telling to me that this gets down voted. Many people here are of the "I me me me mine" mindset, and being down voted for your comment reveals this.
Here you are, sacrificing your own life to make others lives better and peoiple here are like; "Nah..."
Because the point their making that the aim is to drain people of money is wrong.
The purpose of a system is what it does, not what's on its mission statements.
They haven’t yet sacrificed anything except HN points.
Everything is relative. A few more months of life with less pain and more energy to spend it with family surely is a breakthrough for many patients and for the doctors treating them.
But where does it imply less pain? Plus, which pain exactly? Chemotherapy also leads to pain. Prolonging treatment can cause more pain then.
I don't see that as a breakthrough.
You're awfully negative about what a lot of people here see as a breakthrough. Can you be more descriptive about why you don't agree this constitutes a substantial difference other than saying you disagree and dismissing others' opinion?
(not the op) Well, while I understand how fiendishly difficult is to make any progress on cancer and in this type of cancer in particular; and how important is for anyone to be able to add a few months to their life; still I would call something that merely delays your death by 6 months a major improvement but not exactly a breakthrough. A breakthrough is usually something that either solves a problem or at least indicates a new road towards a solution.
If research has been stalled for literal decades, isn't this the very definition of breaking through a tough problem?
In the same sense that breaking through a prison wall to find yourself in a slightly larger cell is a breakthrough.
Or, more realistically, you emerge in the dark, unaware of your new territory, equipped with the tools that got you this far and everything you need to analyze what actually worked with that first prison wall.
You've broken through into the unknown, and maybe there's a fresh wall of unknown composition, but maybe the tools that got you this far can get you further if tweaked.
I don’t think you have ever had to witness somebody undergoing chemotherapy. An alternative, if available is almost always better, and certainly less painful.
Apparently you still need chemo in most cases.
You might as well be antinatalist and there's nothing wrong with that IMO but it otherwise yeah life is of suffering, and until science and politics resolves that we're going to be suffering and dying left and right
Have you looked into Buddhism? Not afraid of suffering, not afraid of death. Duḥkha (suffering) is attaching to the impermanent.
this is like saying Wright brothers didn't make a breakthrough in 1903.
yes, median survival only increased by 7 months, yes, the quality of life is not mentioned. but we are talking about the most lethal cancer at stage 4. the exact same brutal condition that didn't see any treatment improvements for decades.
It sucks less than existing chemo:
> Treatment-related adverse events that led to treatment discontinuation occurred in 1.2% of the patients in the daraxonrasib group and in 11.2% of those in the chemotherapy group.
That's a huge reduction in side effects bad enough to stop treatment.
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2605555?
At the February 2026 data cutoff (median follow-up of 8.5 months), the median overall survival for daraxonrasib was 13.2 months, with a 95% confidence interval of 10.0 months to "not estimable". In contrast, the chemotherapy group's survival data had matured enough to lock in a tight confidence interval of 5.8 to 8.0 months.
So, it could be that the new drug is much much better, but they couldn't tell at the time because they only were trying to say that it was significantly better then chemotherapy.
I think one of the other things the comments I’ve read so far is missing: we rest patients between rounds of treatment to allow time to recuperate. Even surgery and radiation are rough. Chemo is discontinues when your vitals slip too far, and when your time is too short.
Anything that extends your time could allow another round of treatment, with its own over/under that gets you a little more time. So there should be a bit of compound interest here.
That’s like a 100% increase over standard of care.
It's a 2× increase. Huge, but not two orders of magnitude, which would be a 100× increase.
They said 100%, not 100x.
They edited their comment after I replied. Previously it said 2 orders of magnitude.
Mea culpa
In base sqrt(2) it is two orders I guess.
Yes. Doubling median survival, in that population, is massive.
Chemotherapy is very general, this is possibly the first major step towards a cure and massively reshapes the research landscape. From here only time will tell whether this is a dead end or the first major step.
> It won’t cure people with metastatic disease, but it will help a lot live better lives for longer.
Cancer is a problem that can be solved, and it needs to be solved asap. Cancer too often gets either relegated to "Actually, statistically it's very unlikely" by people who don't have it or stylized to the God of Death that unlike other illness we won't solve anytime soon. There is no time to be lost tackling with AI. Dario gets it. Had cancer himself and his father passed away from it.
The thing that makes cancer such a hard problem is that cancer is really a collection of diseases. There's, what, like over a hundred of them? And one organ can produce several unrelated cancers too. I do hope AI will actually be able to figure out the commonalities between all of them and a potential path for a possible even somewhat-universal solution, but I at least don't even know if a universal "cure" is even possible. Granted, my knowledge of biology with respect to cancers is pretty limited.
Cancer is a mutation of cells. There might be 100 known cancers that present in humans, but in theory any mutation can lead to cancer.
Unless we can reliably sign our cells like we do our binaries, we ain't "solving" cancer.
This is exactly the mindset I meant. Look up how people dismissed Neuralink 5 years ago and now it's precise enough to play GTA via. A month ago Tao prognosed that the Riemann hypothesis will be solved in the next 25 years.
It's always impossible until it's done
I think you misunderstood what youre replying to. They're not saying cancers aren't worth fighting, they're saying cancer is not one thing. Theyre replying to the thread that started with "cancer needs to be solved asap", which isnt true or possible because The Cancer Disease doesn't exist.
I am aware of that, and I never said that cancer is a singular disease.
Citation on neuralink?
This is what I've seen:
https://x.com/neuralink/status/2123890949029818800
So the citation... comes from the company itself?
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/wLkKKdBHdi4
I believe this is the GTA VI comment
https://youtube.com/shorts/wLkKKdBHdi4
What's your sense for FTL without time dilation effects?
I mean I get you but the problems you mention are specific to this Earth based middle ground we emerged into.
Others are likely so fundamentally linked to forces we cannot overpower due to the immense amount of variables in physical reality.
Consider a Riemann proof as text is a tiny amount of information relative to all the radiation and stuff floating in space or jiggle at the quantum scale.
Same with a neuralink + brain as our meat suits only want to make sense of things that are familiar.
Cosmic and quantum scale is way different than this stable middle ground we live in. We can still do a lot to stabilize here but I doubt things like space colonization work out given we cannot predict enough of the future to avoid the single catastrophic event that will end all progress and force a do over; Earth's resources can only support giving is so many mulligans. I see limited resources/time as another example of scaling laws just applied across eons.
Even though it's far more far fetched it's probably a better long term goal to focus on Stargate or The Expanse like gate technology rather than chew up Earth's resources chasing Star Trek ships.
You’ve taken the opportunity to glaze Amodei and now Musk in this unrelated thread. Perhaps we can celebrate the actual human researchers and doctors who made this advance.
You had the opportunity to do it in this comment and didn't.
You know BCI was a lively and progressing field before musk ever touched it, right?
And that BCIs have been used for people to play videogames literally since videogames were invented?
Neuralink is a refinement in the field, not a revolution.
edit: Watch the video shared in sibling comments. The big difference in neuralink from BCI SOTA in 1990 is a smaller set of hardware reading your brain (genuine improvement), configurability (minor improvement), and I think a significant improvement in fidelity. The implementation of thinking about moving a body part to give a reader a trivial muscle neural signal to read is older than I am, and has not improved as far as I can tell. That said, the user is demonstrating fine control of a game, so if those advancements were what it took to go from playing Civilization to playing GTA, kudos.
BCIs however are zero percent of the way towards anything like "scanning" your brain or "uploading" your brain, concepts that themselves might not even be physically possible. Even if you could magically copy your brain signals to a computer a la moving a VM, you would not be uploaded to the computer. A clone of your experience would. You still die in misery.
Unfortunately, the primary value Musk brought to the field was a willingness to invest money. Time and time again, his cultish supporters mistake a banal investment in engineering as groundbreaking, because they completely ignore the total lack of investment before he waved his cash around. We don't need musk to invest in things. We need a willingness to spend money towards goals. Also maybe read some magazines. BCIs were something Popular Science talked about occasionally, which is one of the ways I know about prior art in the field.
Well solving the 100 we very well could be solving cancer for 99.5% of folks while still not “solving” cancer.
300 answers to unsolved problems were dropped all at once by a frontier lab
there doesn’t even need to be a commonality, all will get solved
I hear ML researchers are even picking up smoking again
There is a key difference between what AI has solved so far and most types of cancer: A digital representation that can be manipulated as a surrogate.
For many cancers we don’t have a good animal model or cell model, let alone a simulation.
AI can and will help us identify good targets for treatment, but the learning loop will be full of slow non deterministic biomedical experiments.
I suspect it will take far fewer of those experiments for AI to develop a good simulation model of the phenomena at work than it has historically takens for humans to be able to understand and characterize it. Anthropic is already working on this: they're building a wet lab where researchers will conduct Claude-designed experiments. It really is kinda like Aperture Science, which (for me) is a source of both awe and concern.
I am looking forward to this. After the wet lab there will then be the clinical trial phases 1,2,3 and continuous evaluation in application.
These are the real bottlenecks.
Don’t get me wrong I am supper excited about the progress, at the same time I’d not start with smoking.
This is satire, right? We're in a thread that says "wow, for once no hyperbole" - which one cannot help but associate with the lack of AI references in the article - and here we are a few comments deep with breathless AI hyperbole. Complete with cult personality worship.
I can't tell anymore.
I understand it's hard to burn through an 8-figure marketing budget but this is wild.
AI is dancing and sparkling its way towards solutions we've struggled with for decades if not centuries. That's not hyperbole; it's the reality we're currently dealing with. It portends both unimaginable well-being for us all (or at least those who could still afford it) as well as a complete deflation of our sense of purpose besides merely existing and keeping the machine's data troughs fed.
The commonality on all of AI's huge accomplishments so far is fast feedback, immediately verifiably true (assuming you trust Lean) answers. It is very far from being able to make the claim that it can do the same in clinical research.
>AI is dancing and sparkling its way towards solutions we've struggled with for decades if not centuries
In math.
Are you referencing something like Riemann hypothesis, which it came out 6 hours later someone had already written a proof for with zero AI? I think AI is great and will have its use cases, but I think your drinking the kool-aid a bit too much.
The human-written proof is not verified and contains several errors, it's not unlikely that there is one that breaks the whole proof because this has happened plenty of times for Riemann.
The Alpöge/Claude one is already verified.
Masullo's proof has severe flaws in it. The Claude proof has been mechanically checked and found to be valid (with respect to the produced Lean formalization).
Nope, I’ve drank the koolaid,
I’ve seen some of what’s going on with “long horizon” training and how it’s being applied to life sciences
I can extrapolate what that means and it bolsters my confidence into what I wrote
For starters, you might want to do some research into the origins of that expression.
yeah cultists march towards their self inflected death as they actually drank poisonous liquid
e/acc
Honestly with all the bad press, I'm still determined and hope for a better future where this becomes reality. I just hope the focus shifts towards that, it would be an incredible achievement.
Which cancer? I ask because the specific thing preventing “a cancer cure” is the fact that cancers are only vaguely related. It’s like saying “broken bone is a problem that can be solved.”
Yes, it can, but to imply it’s simply one disease is missing completely the exact reason why it’s so hard to cure.
Cancer can be solved, and that's one thing I agree with Dario on. (His scare tactics and gatekeeping on the other hand actually slow down research.)
Agreed, if this was Dario's priority then there have been numerous missteps along the way that did more harm than good.
Its actually crazy all of these threads end up being about how good AI is, when the post has 0 to do with AI.
need help
Did this comment get cut off, or maybe you replied to the wrong one?
“claude, the cancer please. and don’t make any mistakes!!!”
ur right bro, what were we thinking not trying to cure cancer!!!!
RAS is a (class of) proteins in the membrane of your cells that are important in telling cells when it is time to grow. These proteins cycle between an "active" state that stimulates growth and an "inactive" state that doesn't. An extremely common genetic mutation that happens as a person develops cancer causes some of these cells to start making RAS proteins that do not correctly switch back to the "inactive" state. The cells with these mutations then grow and divide very rapidly and can become a tumor. Daraxonrasib works by binding the active state RAS proteins and preventing them from signalling and triggering growth. This can help prevent the tumors from growing further and potentially even shrink them as they are attacked by the immune system or other medication.
(I'm not an expert, just a fan of knowing how things work, anyone can correct me if they know better)
In case others are wondering, it looks like this is a different story than this recent one:
Pancreatic cancer halted by virus injection in three patients - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50563066 - Nov 2026 (157 comments)
Yes, FOLFIRINOX is a combination of chemotherapeutic agents.
Which is very different from being administered an adenovirus (VRT106) that recognizes a receptor often expressed on cancer cells (MXRA8), that after ‘infecting’ the cell triggers direct oncolysis and indirect immunogenic responses.
Did you reply to the wrong comment? The article is about Daraxonrasib, a RAS inhibitor sold under the brand name Rasonque, not Folfirinox.
The article is about Daraxonrasib. The comment you are replying to is about Folfirinox. Hopefully that clears it up...
No — dang's comment is about an adenovirus therapy, while grandparent mentions Folfirinox, which seems like a non sequitur since nobody mentioned it.
Oh, I just assumed they were the same, incredible that there's now two very promising approaches for pancreatic cancer..!
There's also incremental improvements in chemo therapy and radiation therapy. Example: Elmedix and its heat treatment.
People who pay a lot of attention to US news might know this as the therapy former senator and UF president Ben Sasse is taking.
“Last week, the former senator from Nebraska Ben Sasse announced that his Stage 4 pancreatic cancer had developed resistance to a cutting edge treatment.“
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/30/science/pancreatic-cancer...
Irrelevant aside, but that's a nice garden path sentence. My brain threw a couple of exceptions trying to parse what a "therapy former senator" is before finally realizing it's "the therapy [...] Ben Sasse is taking".
TIL! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden-path_sentence
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Really_Achieving_Your_Childhoo...
Does the -ib medication suffix have meaning? I know -ab medications like Benralizumab, Canakinumab, etc are monoclonal antibodies. The only -ib I can remember other than this new one is Imatinib, which is also a cancer treatment, so maybe it's to do with cancer?
The suffix -ib stands for inhibitor, but it's not a standalone suffix as such.
In this case the "real" suffix is -rasib, meaning RAS inhibitor. This is the "stem" defined by the WHO [1].
You have other suffixes like -coxib (for COX inhibitors like celecoxib) and -nib (for kinase inhibitors like upadacitinib, where -citinib then refers to JAK/TYK type kinase).
Monoclonal antibodies end with -mab, not -ab.
[1] https://www.who.int/teams/health-product-and-policy-standard...
It’s a category called small-molecule drug. I take a medication called upadacitinib for ulcerative colitis. Previously, I took monoclonal antibodies called Ustekinumab and vedolizumab.
These medication-categories are not only prevalent in cancer therapy.
If you look at the molecular size, -ibs are very small and -mabs really huge.
Inhibitor, in this case for the Ras GTPase protein
I’m not in biotech so I don’t understand how approvals work, but it sounds like it’s already being used and that patients develop a resistance to it and it stops working. Perhaps someone in the field can help explain the dissonance between these articles.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/30/science/pancreatic-cancer...
There isn’t a dissonance. It can be both a breakthrough and just a first step. A median survival in the trial of 13 months means 50% of participants died in 13 months or less, which is simultaneously an exciting advance (in this disease, in 2L) and a tragedy.
The answer as to why is for ongoing investigation. Cancers are complex entities, and a single patient’s cancer may have multiple mechanisms capable of driving its growth. Daraxonrasib blocks several of these mechanisms, but in time, either some of the suppressed mechanisms escape its suppression, or other mechanisms which aren’t suppressed become more active and continue the growth.
I do hope to see more progress on medicine with AI.
If we can prove GRH with AI we really should be able to cure cancer.
I really hope so too! And I think it will help.
But people need to keep in mind how much money there is in math proofs before they get too excited. In short: there's very little. Mathematicians are often regarded as a pinnacle of human intelligence, but most of them are working at universities and working on these problems in their off time.
There are a few exceptions, but they are very rare. Anthropic is apparently paying people to do this kind of work full time. They've also been also dumping orders of magnitude more money into these problems than we've spent in the past.
It's not like cancer research. Cancer isn't an equation that will be cured as soon as it's proven, and solving it isn't a hobby that a professor has to juggle with teaching duties. This is already a billion dollar research field that is data limited, subject to ethical considerations, and extremely complicated logistically. AI can help with all that, but it won't be solved by forking Claude 15M worth of tokens.
On the other hand, it would be great if Anthropic wants to fork 15M worth of tokens the rare research software engineer who is struggling to integrate the 15 proprietary data formats their lab uses into a coherent database. Maybe they can help build a database that streamlines data sharing, or improves logistics to set up studies. There's a lot to hope for here!
AI is acting on perfect information in arenas like GRH and Chess.
The human body is not a game like chess. There is hidden information everywhere: stuff nobody ever tried to measure, stuff that somebody tried to measure and got it wrong, and the stuff people tried to measure and actually got right.
An AI can’t just deduce a prior hard physical facts about people.
And I’m pretty sure the stuff people measured correctly is a tiny fraction of all the features and data that are relevant to cancer in a human body.
The difference is not perfect information, it is verifiability which allows for infinite training data.
AI doesn't get perfect information in poker, yet it's the best at poker because poker is verifiable, meaning infinite training data.
The question is how to get lots of training data for bio. I like Jeff Dean's company for this.
Outsider to the domain, but I am hopeful that one day ML and classical techniques can be combined to simulate proteins and cells in-silico at many orders of magnitude speedup. We know the math, it’s just too slow to model it all today.
It's not "slow", it's computationally intractable
You cannot simulate a human. Not even in theory. There's no magic AI can find to overcome that.
There aren't enough atoms in the universe to even contain a theoretical computer able to do it.
The universe will always be dramatically faster at "running" atoms and interactions than a computer, because a computer will always have to explicitly do the work of summing up interactions with all other atoms and particles, something the universe itself gets "for free".
Part of the possible speedup from things like quantum computers is taking advantage of the fact that the universe will "run" a set of interactions faster and with higher fidelity than you ever could hope
What you can do, though, is develop abstract or ML models that approximate the behavior of some object. The model is designed to run thousands, millions, billions of times faster. You can benchmark this abstract model against the actual mathematical simulation for general correctness within error bars. Then you can use it.
I mean, that’s what happens in other domains that cross into intractability.
Maybe you're assuming the parent comment meant on the same timescale as GRH was solved.
Otherwise I feel the parent's comment is perfectly reasonable.
Cancer is simply a fatal combination of mutations that results in a set of cells that no longer follow the regulations in place that the organism uses to control unbounded and out of place growth of that or those cells.
I see no reason AI would be unable to help with such a simple problem statement.
In many ways cancer is simpler than the Riemann hypothesis to attack.
The complexity of cancer, from what I've studied, isn't that we don't understand what's broken about the cells. It's that we don't manipulate matter as efficiently as biology to attack those broken cells.
Just this week news hit about a virus that can stop pancreatic cancer in its tracks.
Now why can the virus do this and not our medicines?
Because viruses work on the same scale of matter manipulation and process genetic information at the same physical scale that our cells do.
You're right that the ability to emit tokens, no matter how intelligent, is tangential to our ability to manipulate matter.
However DNA and RNA can be expressed as tokens.
Thus one can imagine that just as AI has helped us emit information via language and code tokens faster, it ought to be able to emit DNA sequences faster than any human typing out A's, T's, C's and G's by hand.
Thus, I can imagine a world in which cancer cell sequencing happens much faster and viral targets for those cancer cells are written by AI as easily as they write code today.
That AIs have somehow managed to wrangle all human information to advance human capability in a variety of domains is promising because individual humans likely have no hope of wrangling, in a single human mind, all of the genetic, physical, and chemical pathways in a living organism as complex as a human.
I'm not predicting when this happens but given that there are already services that will print a custom DNA or RNA strand to order, I absolutely see a world in which viruses, custom-designed to attack an individual's cancer cells bearing genetic markers matching the cancer cell type (e.g breast, lung, etc.) and mutations should be possible since fundamentally biology is built on information (RNA and DNA).
So I agree with you that we shouldn't expect a "cancer cure" in the next 6 months.
But since cancer starts in the information-holding part of the cell, building therapies that are information-sensitive with a previously unimagined rapid turnaround, and packaged in a virus which may also be heavily genetically modified to suit this purpose, does seem like exactly the type of problem these new generative manipulators of information are built to solve.
The only troubling thing is, can’t the same orders be placed for extremely deadly and contagious viruses ?
> And I’m pretty sure the stuff people measured correctly is a tiny fraction of all the features and data that are relevant to cancer in a human body.
AI can now, or will soon be able to deduce:
* what additional data it needs to gather
* how to conduct measurements to gather that data
* once gathered, what the data portends in terms of the mechanism of action of cancer
* what course of treatment will kill the cancer with a minimum of interference with healthy body cells
All we would have to do is feed it enormous amounts of the right kind of information and it could come up with a treatment that will vastly ameliorate many kinds of cancers. Anthropic is already working on this; they have a wet lab where the biologists are "meat proxies" conducting experiments for Claude which is developing new drug candidates. This is already happening.
I'm realistic enough to understand that a total or near-total cure for pancreatic cancer won't happen tomorrow. But it will still be very soon compared to the time horizon typical of medical research, wherein progress happens very slowly over decades.
AI will, but the most important thing we need is directors to guide it, same as GRH
Right now AI can check images and give you accurate diagnosis. But that is something already there. We need to prevent, better than cure. And to prevent we need more info about the causes, we need more strict rules about environmental contamination, same as we did with smoking. We need to understand the influence of drugs, chemicals, food, stress, in the development of cancer. We need to put all knowledge in one place in order to allow specialists and geniuses to find solutions. Creating walled silos of knowledge is in benefit of none but a few, that's why open weights, open models, and open knowledge is extremely important for us all
I think the future will be better for those who prevent it, not just cure it. Accurate prevention will make us immune to cancer
I hope we see more progress on medicine with or without AI, personally.
I don't understand why you would believe developing a formal proof and developing a successful medical intervention share any relevant commonalities. They share neither problem structure nor solution space and require materially different forms of labor. Math is handy in that it is notably divorced from material and biological reality. Oncology notably less so.
um, the AI is highly intelligent, thats why
“If we can make data smaller we can make cancer smaller” - Gavin Belson
No lean for medicin
We can hope that the treatment will be accessible to the most still as it's been dicovered in the US
My former boss, one of the nicest, kindest and most jovial guys I've ever known, had pancreatic cancer. He quite literally wasted away before our eyes and died within a year. He was a big, round guy in life, but lying in his casket, it was like someone had let all the air out of a balloon. There wasn't anything left of him.
Pancreatic cancer is nasty (most cancers are), but the recent breakthroughs make me hopeful that we'll one day see a world where it won't be so devastating.
And the study from Barbacid, Liaki y Guerra is not mentioned at all, after being retracted by a conflict of interests.
Former PM of Czechia, Topolánek, suffers from pancreatic cancer and is very open about it in the media.
Accidentally I know him personally, we lived in the same city. A tough guy, though not an angel; anyway, politics aside, I am glad that he is still alive and that he did a huge job opening the debate on pancreatic cancer and its possible prevention or early treatment.
He is also a frequent guest in podcasts and I noticed lately that his face looks really weird, as if scalded. I believe this is a side-effect of daraxonrasib. He mentioned something about experimental treatment.
It would be amazing to live in a time we could say, "remember when cancer was a thing?"
You know, like we do now with measles.
I don't know if you intentionally mentioned measles but as of a few days ago, we officially can't say measles "was" a thing (at least here in the U.S.)...
https://www.uchealth.org/today/is-measles-deadly-why-it-is-s...
...or Canada, or the UK, or Germany, or various other countries.
We currently have a cancer vaccine (Gardasil) and lots of people "don't agree with it," including people who aren't generally anti-vaccine.
Rasonque (daraxonrasib
$480,000/year price tag
44% severe side effect rate
a few months extra survival
I call bs on the "biggest breakthrough in decades" unless this is referring to the manufacturer's bottom line.
Really don't get this cynicism. And it's in every thread about this topic.
Once something like this have been invented, we (humanity) have them forever. Long after the patent for Rasonque expires in 14 more years and it sells for cost plus some margin. Lipitor was once the most profitable drug in the world and now my mother takes it for $4/month. For a cancer example, Keytruda is going off patent soon. We will have that incredible gift forever. The inventor repayment period (patent protection) only lasts a little while in the grand scheme.
Let me be clearer - this drug is expensive garbage. There are several cancer drugs that are currently being studied that appear to be orders of magnitude more effective for prostate cancer, without the severe side effects. Unfortunately for the pharmaceutical industry, they are no longer under patent so there is no $$ to be made.
Sorry what? Prostate cancer is one of the most survivable cancers (98% 5-year survival rate) and pancreatic cancer, which is what the post is about, is the lowest (13% 5-year survival rate). I think you got confused. This is a major breakthrough for pancreatic cancer. Nothing like this exists anywhere.
And your claim about off-patent treatments not being used because they can't make money is just simply incorrect. Trastuzumab, Oxaliplatin (used for pancreatic btw), Rituximab, Bevacizumab, and many other therapies are all examples of front-line cancer treatments in 2026 that are off-patent. A vial of Fluorouracil is like $8. It's the standard front-line treatment for Colorectal Cancer, prescribed in about 95% of metastatic cases.
yes this is worse kind of cancer with no much tretament , would have saved steve jobs
It almost certainly wouldn’t have. He had a different type of tumour.
The article conflates tumor with cancer.
Does the pill address both pancreatic cancer and tumor or just one of them?
Just different words for effectively the same thing.
Hope this is the start of a new age of inexpensive cures & treatments that will be available to everyone, regardless of financial status :)
FUCK YES. Sorry, just good to read, what seems to be, real progress.
Steve Jobs would've funded the shit outta this.
Daraxonrasib is mostly about the common types of pancreatic cancer, mostly PDAC with KRAS mutations. Jobs had a PNET (Pancreatic neuroendocrine tumor) that typically doesn't have a KRAS mutation, and has a much better prognosis compared to the death sentence that PDAC is. But he shot himself in the foot by delaying his whipple procedure.
the guy that treated his cancer with smoothies?
We'll look back at the era of chemotherapy and surgery as barbarism
The hope is the nearly all of our current treatments will be considered barbaric in the not so soon future
Kinase inhibitors are a kind of chemotherapy.
If it's the best we have, and up to a point it works, seems pretty gross to call it barbaric. Saved a lot of people's lives, saved my mother.
There's only one sure treatment for all types of cancers and that is gene repair. But pharmaceutical companies aren't interested because repairing genes cannot be patented. The future is being delayed because of corporate interests.