Ladakh is pretty unique place - if you want to ever experience Tibet how it was before Chinese rolled in with tanks, go there. India is polytheistic state by principle so buddhists are not oppressed and north east and north west regions are full of cca same local population plus all the Tibetan refugees. Also the 19h journey with minibus from Manali crossing through vast valleys was very intense, sometimes with no road at all and going above 5000m altitude.
I've traveled a bit around the world but it was the only place I 'felt' some sort of inner light / peace emanating from folks there. I guess Buddhism effect but its not universal, ie war torn Sri Lanka was different (which is completely understandable).
I recently had the fortune of being able to visit ladakh and the feeling of guilt was profound. I saw some of the kindest people, yet they were overlooked for even basic amenities. The only reason there were even good roads at all were for military purposes. The ecnomic disparities was star - kids working in petrol pump and selling things on the street.
It is heartbreaking to see that the people who are least responsible for climate change will be hit the hardest.
That's basic geography in action. This area is not simply remote but extremely far from the world ocean, making meaningful trade very expensive. And it is on the other side of the Himalaya, making rain/agriculture difficult. Altruism cannot fix such realities.
By google maps, it is 1500km and the Himalaya to the south, or 3000km and all of China to the west.
Are they? I mean "responsible" due to an act of will? Or are they just less responsible because of chance?
My theory is that if I'd give the people of Ladakh money (or better yet: a steady source of money), then they would adopt an equally lavish life style and economy as other places of the world. They would have a similar CO2 foot print. Maybe even a worse one: often bribes make wonders true and then plants abuse the environment tenfold compared to a similar-purpose plant in e.g. France.
Yeah, I could afford to fly in, stay at a nice hotel with good food, warm water and electricity. I can go back before the weather got back or incase of a flood.
Because GP has an understanding of global systemic disparities that afford some groups some privileges at the cost of some other groups becoming underprivileged and perhaps outright abused.
I.e., we can enjoy cheap tropical fruits (not to mention coffee, cocoa, and vanilla) all year round because of the abuse of farmers in other countries, or cheap electronics because of 996 assembly lines.
And once you take advantage of these opportunities, you’re also supporting and prolonging the existence of such inequalities that enable them, hence the feeling of guilt.
Chinese tourists generally do not feel guilt and anxiety at "global systemic disparities" when they visit such places or enjoy fruit and coffee. One can fairly view Westerners' feelings here as a quirk of their own culture, a learned response, and it doesn't necessarily have to be that way.
I think you are focusing too much on analyzing some esoteric, western economics based group-thought.
Mate, it's just empathy. Empathy is a normal human reaction that allows the brain to compartmentalize and file away overwhelming grief, anxiety, worry etc.
It is completely normal to see a poor individual/group/area and think "Despite no contribution of my own or of theres, I feel bad".
That's just common empathy, we're all people and in a world of abundance some of us can have so much while others are still in abject poverty.
If you don't have a sliver of guilt when you see other people in those conditions while you can have many comforts (many times supported only by the exploitation of people living like that) perhaps you gotta exercise more empathy.
Which is the chicken and which the egg? For many individuals at the bottom of the pecking order nothing much changes if you do or do not turn up on time, you are close to as badly off either way way. The benefits to society as a whole come from people en masse doing the right thing and that requires organization. It's difficult to organize when you are poor and most need it.
Also it sounds like you are generalising as though all the poor in the world are poor for the same reasons. No doubt some are poor for the reasons you describe, but others are poor because the environment in which they live is resource poor and the climate hostile.
This is completely false. I live in a very poor country. People don't work even when it will clearly change their circumstances. They don't even bother to do things like spell the name of their business correctly in Google Maps, or answer their phone when someone wants to pay them, or show up for jobs. Things that even a child would realize are helpful. It absolutely will benefit them to behave in a professional way. They just don't care.
Really, if you have never lived in a country like this you can't realize what I'm talking about. If you have, its extremely obviously true.
From what i remember, India used to be a relatively well off society with very clean streets.
But colonialism and the industrial era hits poor countries hard, hence why India is so poor and focused moreso on production rather than cleanliness.
Industrial England used to be the same, look at the great stink of the River Thames.
The industrial barons have no real reason to change their society, since they barely live in it. It's not until somone like Lee Kuan Yew, or Deng Xiaoping takes a look around, and successfully reshapes their society to what it once was (or ascend to heights never seen in Singapore's case).
The well off society with clean streets existed when British ruled India. It's destroyed when Indians ruled India and made it free-for-all. Unlimited migration into few metropolitan cities from rest of the country is not sustainable. Corruption also is more pervasive than the British India. There's even a slur for corrupt government officials ("Babu"). Third, there's a social justice mentality which breeds entitlement and greed. "He can get X, why can't I" is everywhere. Of course this has nothing to do with Caste and Hindutva memes spread by shallow clickbait journalists in the western publications.
I partially believe that some of it came after British extraction of wealth from India. It's possible some of it is native to India itself. But I lean moreso to Colonial influence.
India was notable for being very wealthy before the British influence, but British and Western influence was very notable in the creation of the modern Indian State, which didn't really exist as a single entity prior.
Colonies, for whatever reason, seem like a more "extreme" version of the nations which colonize them. This is why America is extremely individualistic, extremely hardworking, but also extremely hard against the idea of "handouts". This is due to there being no one to extract wealth from, and therefore, had to mostly produce it themselves (except in the South).
In contrast, India and other societies that had native people living there prior to British colonization, become massively corrupt as the British which lived there, lived only to extract wealth rather than produce it as seen in the U.S.
As such, Liberia as an example, which stems from African Americans who fled from slavery, descended into a neo-slave owning class held by African Americans, who simply tried to recreate the society they came from, but now as the dominant class.
That's a sweeping generalization. There are many reasons for poverty and they vary significantly across countries and cultures. Fr example, scarcity plays a big role in explaining why poor countries are poor (https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/cid/publications/books/s...)
If only they moved to America, corruption and dishonesty can get you to the top of the richest list, and the top job in government! (Actually no, only American born corrupt twats can be president)
What an utterly clueless comment; You need some major education in Politics/Economics/Finance/etc.
The main problem is the rigged global system via the institutions built by colonialism which were designed to extract labour/value from the developing world. These have morphed into the modern post-colonial structures but with the same implicit one-way resource extraction which continue to this day (eg. IMF, World Bank etc.). If everything in the Environment is stacked against you, no amount of "good" culture/choices/etc can help you. It is the entire System (i.e. Proper Institutions, Conducive Environment, No debt trap/austerity, Corruption etc) that must be attacked and reformed.
Now you are just trying to gaslight by asking irrelevant silly questions. But yes i have lived for a decade-and-half in a developed country.
That is the reason i know both sides of the story and feel very strongly about people bringing up colonial-era tropes to explain away the problems and inequalities in the world.
What you are talking about are symptoms and not causal factors though they can act as catalysts in the system either for betterment or detriment.
You need to go through the resources i gave you (and more) to understand the actual issues involved. Also read about Incentivization, its connection to Extrinsic/Intrinsic motivations and use in system building - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incentivisation
Mine is a very tiny data-point. I think this is becoming a problem in quite a lot of other rural parts of India. Recently, I needed to visit my home-town (a tiny state that borders with Myanmar), and Degue is “epidemic” there. Mosquitoe problems has not gone down with time but has regressed real bad. It was not even that bad when I was growing up in the 80s, 90s.
Anyone noticed an increase in mosquitoes in Texas? I don't have data to back that up but I feel like I can't sit outside as often as I used to because of mosquitoes
We need to wipe out mosquitoes once and for all. I know it’s cruel, how is it morally righteous of us to prevent malaria killing people, malaria deserves rights too yada yada. Let’s just do it. Enough people have died.
I don't think there's any major opposition claiming virus/bacteria having rights. It's more about eradicating an entire species that are part of the food chain might bring up unexpected result.
For starters, we don't actually need to eradicate most mosquitoes, most of them don't spread diseases at all, and some of their larvae actually eat the disease-spreading ones. We've successfully infected mosquito populations with Wolbachia to prevent them from spreading diseases, and since they pass the infection to the offspring, it's self-sustaining.
Note that I'm not some hippie who has only ever seen mosquitoes when glamping. They're endemic in most of my country, I've had dengue fever and malaria separately in my teenage years, and I'm still annoyed by them disturbing my sleep to this very day. I use bug spray liberally when possible, a fan to keep them away if not, and I thoroughly support any measure to control and modify the population. I just don't think we should bring all of them to extinction.
As far as I can recall this has been extensively studied and the conclusion was no great damage to the ecosystem would be caused by eradication pathogen hosting mosquitos.
You can search HN even -- many articles on this topic posted here and discussed whose details I cannot remember at the top of my head. Those articles would point to the investigations and studies.
You would maybe love the mosquito zapper racket I used to use when growing up.
I felt like zeus striking the mortal mosquitoes with electricity and also improved my agility and control since it was flimsy product and you don’t want to hit anything with it.
Doesn’t eradicate mosquitoes but sure as hell gave me the feeling of control. :P
Ladakh is pretty unique place - if you want to ever experience Tibet how it was before Chinese rolled in with tanks, go there. India is polytheistic state by principle so buddhists are not oppressed and north east and north west regions are full of cca same local population plus all the Tibetan refugees. Also the 19h journey with minibus from Manali crossing through vast valleys was very intense, sometimes with no road at all and going above 5000m altitude.
I've traveled a bit around the world but it was the only place I 'felt' some sort of inner light / peace emanating from folks there. I guess Buddhism effect but its not universal, ie war torn Sri Lanka was different (which is completely understandable).
Well, India has an actual piece of Tibet: Arunachal Pradesh.
I recently had the fortune of being able to visit ladakh and the feeling of guilt was profound. I saw some of the kindest people, yet they were overlooked for even basic amenities. The only reason there were even good roads at all were for military purposes. The ecnomic disparities was star - kids working in petrol pump and selling things on the street.
It is heartbreaking to see that the people who are least responsible for climate change will be hit the hardest.
That's basic geography in action. This area is not simply remote but extremely far from the world ocean, making meaningful trade very expensive. And it is on the other side of the Himalaya, making rain/agriculture difficult. Altruism cannot fix such realities.
By google maps, it is 1500km and the Himalaya to the south, or 3000km and all of China to the west.
> who are least responsible for climate change
Are they? I mean "responsible" due to an act of will? Or are they just less responsible because of chance?
My theory is that if I'd give the people of Ladakh money (or better yet: a steady source of money), then they would adopt an equally lavish life style and economy as other places of the world. They would have a similar CO2 foot print. Maybe even a worse one: often bribes make wonders true and then plants abuse the environment tenfold compared to a similar-purpose plant in e.g. France.
Guilt?
Yeah, I could afford to fly in, stay at a nice hotel with good food, warm water and electricity. I can go back before the weather got back or incase of a flood.
Most of the locals could do none of this.
And why should you feel guilty for that?
Because GP has an understanding of global systemic disparities that afford some groups some privileges at the cost of some other groups becoming underprivileged and perhaps outright abused.
I.e., we can enjoy cheap tropical fruits (not to mention coffee, cocoa, and vanilla) all year round because of the abuse of farmers in other countries, or cheap electronics because of 996 assembly lines.
And once you take advantage of these opportunities, you’re also supporting and prolonging the existence of such inequalities that enable them, hence the feeling of guilt.
Chinese tourists generally do not feel guilt and anxiety at "global systemic disparities" when they visit such places or enjoy fruit and coffee. One can fairly view Westerners' feelings here as a quirk of their own culture, a learned response, and it doesn't necessarily have to be that way.
The fact that tigers don't feel remorse when eating goats doesn't mean vegetarians are wrong.
Tiger eating herbivores means that herbivores are not wrong?
Maybe it means that vegetarians are tasty.
I mean, "vegetarians are goats" is certainly a conclusion one could draw from what I said.
I think you are focusing too much on analyzing some esoteric, western economics based group-thought.
Mate, it's just empathy. Empathy is a normal human reaction that allows the brain to compartmentalize and file away overwhelming grief, anxiety, worry etc.
It is completely normal to see a poor individual/group/area and think "Despite no contribution of my own or of theres, I feel bad".
I'm literally from india
Are you implying it is wrong to feel guilt (or empathy) for global systemic failures?
That's just common empathy, we're all people and in a world of abundance some of us can have so much while others are still in abject poverty.
If you don't have a sliver of guilt when you see other people in those conditions while you can have many comforts (many times supported only by the exploitation of people living like that) perhaps you gotta exercise more empathy.
Exactly due to the reasons the others just stated here. I am part of the problem and a beneficiary of the system that caused it.
[flagged]
Which is the chicken and which the egg? For many individuals at the bottom of the pecking order nothing much changes if you do or do not turn up on time, you are close to as badly off either way way. The benefits to society as a whole come from people en masse doing the right thing and that requires organization. It's difficult to organize when you are poor and most need it.
Also it sounds like you are generalising as though all the poor in the world are poor for the same reasons. No doubt some are poor for the reasons you describe, but others are poor because the environment in which they live is resource poor and the climate hostile.
This is completely false. I live in a very poor country. People don't work even when it will clearly change their circumstances. They don't even bother to do things like spell the name of their business correctly in Google Maps, or answer their phone when someone wants to pay them, or show up for jobs. Things that even a child would realize are helpful. It absolutely will benefit them to behave in a professional way. They just don't care.
Really, if you have never lived in a country like this you can't realize what I'm talking about. If you have, its extremely obviously true.
Yesn't,
From what i remember, India used to be a relatively well off society with very clean streets.
But colonialism and the industrial era hits poor countries hard, hence why India is so poor and focused moreso on production rather than cleanliness.
Industrial England used to be the same, look at the great stink of the River Thames.
The industrial barons have no real reason to change their society, since they barely live in it. It's not until somone like Lee Kuan Yew, or Deng Xiaoping takes a look around, and successfully reshapes their society to what it once was (or ascend to heights never seen in Singapore's case).
The well off society with clean streets existed when British ruled India. It's destroyed when Indians ruled India and made it free-for-all. Unlimited migration into few metropolitan cities from rest of the country is not sustainable. Corruption also is more pervasive than the British India. There's even a slur for corrupt government officials ("Babu"). Third, there's a social justice mentality which breeds entitlement and greed. "He can get X, why can't I" is everywhere. Of course this has nothing to do with Caste and Hindutva memes spread by shallow clickbait journalists in the western publications.
I partially believe that some of it came after British extraction of wealth from India. It's possible some of it is native to India itself. But I lean moreso to Colonial influence.
India was notable for being very wealthy before the British influence, but British and Western influence was very notable in the creation of the modern Indian State, which didn't really exist as a single entity prior.
Colonies, for whatever reason, seem like a more "extreme" version of the nations which colonize them. This is why America is extremely individualistic, extremely hardworking, but also extremely hard against the idea of "handouts". This is due to there being no one to extract wealth from, and therefore, had to mostly produce it themselves (except in the South).
In contrast, India and other societies that had native people living there prior to British colonization, become massively corrupt as the British which lived there, lived only to extract wealth rather than produce it as seen in the U.S.
As such, Liberia as an example, which stems from African Americans who fled from slavery, descended into a neo-slave owning class held by African Americans, who simply tried to recreate the society they came from, but now as the dominant class.
That's a sweeping generalization. There are many reasons for poverty and they vary significantly across countries and cultures. Fr example, scarcity plays a big role in explaining why poor countries are poor (https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/cid/publications/books/s...)
The list of reasons you list (besides corruption) are not at all mentioned here for reasons of poverty in Africa: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_Africa
Do you think this wikipedia article is ever going to tell you the real reasons Africa is poor...
If not, maybe you can update it (citing sources of course) and enlighten us! It's the whole point of Wikipedia.
If only they moved to America, corruption and dishonesty can get you to the top of the richest list, and the top job in government! (Actually no, only American born corrupt twats can be president)
If you made a coherent point it escaped me
Add it to the long list of things you can't fathom...
What an utterly clueless comment; You need some major education in Politics/Economics/Finance/etc.
The main problem is the rigged global system via the institutions built by colonialism which were designed to extract labour/value from the developing world. These have morphed into the modern post-colonial structures but with the same implicit one-way resource extraction which continue to this day (eg. IMF, World Bank etc.). If everything in the Environment is stacked against you, no amount of "good" culture/choices/etc can help you. It is the entire System (i.e. Proper Institutions, Conducive Environment, No debt trap/austerity, Corruption etc) that must be attacked and reformed.
1) How Unequal Exchange Shapes Our World - https://www.hamptonthink.org/read/how-unequal-exchange-shape...
2) Unequal exchange of labour in the world economy - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-49687-y
3) The effects of IMF loan conditions on poverty in the developing world - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9172087/
4) Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty by Acemoglu et al. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_Nations_Fail
5) Culture and Poverty; Critique and Counter-proposals by Charles Valentine (this is an old classic but fundamental book) - https://archive.org/details/culturepovertycr0000unse_a8i8
Have you ever lived in the third world?
I live in one; your point?
Read the articles/books i linked to above so you don't make inane statements about things you seem to have no clue about.
Have you also lived in the first world? Have you experienced the massive gulf when it comes to the professionalism of the average person?
Now you are just trying to gaslight by asking irrelevant silly questions. But yes i have lived for a decade-and-half in a developed country.
That is the reason i know both sides of the story and feel very strongly about people bringing up colonial-era tropes to explain away the problems and inequalities in the world.
What you are talking about are symptoms and not causal factors though they can act as catalysts in the system either for betterment or detriment.
You need to go through the resources i gave you (and more) to understand the actual issues involved. Also read about Incentivization, its connection to Extrinsic/Intrinsic motivations and use in system building - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incentivisation
Mine is a very tiny data-point. I think this is becoming a problem in quite a lot of other rural parts of India. Recently, I needed to visit my home-town (a tiny state that borders with Myanmar), and Degue is “epidemic” there. Mosquitoe problems has not gone down with time but has regressed real bad. It was not even that bad when I was growing up in the 80s, 90s.
Anyone noticed an increase in mosquitoes in Texas? I don't have data to back that up but I feel like I can't sit outside as often as I used to because of mosquitoes
We need to wipe out mosquitoes once and for all. I know it’s cruel, how is it morally righteous of us to prevent malaria killing people, malaria deserves rights too yada yada. Let’s just do it. Enough people have died.
I don't think there's any major opposition claiming virus/bacteria having rights. It's more about eradicating an entire species that are part of the food chain might bring up unexpected result.
For starters, we don't actually need to eradicate most mosquitoes, most of them don't spread diseases at all, and some of their larvae actually eat the disease-spreading ones. We've successfully infected mosquito populations with Wolbachia to prevent them from spreading diseases, and since they pass the infection to the offspring, it's self-sustaining.
Note that I'm not some hippie who has only ever seen mosquitoes when glamping. They're endemic in most of my country, I've had dengue fever and malaria separately in my teenage years, and I'm still annoyed by them disturbing my sleep to this very day. I use bug spray liberally when possible, a fan to keep them away if not, and I thoroughly support any measure to control and modify the population. I just don't think we should bring all of them to extinction.
As far as I can recall this has been extensively studied and the conclusion was no great damage to the ecosystem would be caused by eradication pathogen hosting mosquitos.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosquito_control#Proposals_to_... (not very comprehensive)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49956290
This is well trodden ground but granted that is not an insurance against mistaken judgement.
"Tobacco is good for children, it has been extensively studied without finding any harm" (70's Tobacco makers)
"extensively studied"... by whom?
By ecologists.
You can search HN even -- many articles on this topic posted here and discussed whose details I cannot remember at the top of my head. Those articles would point to the investigations and studies.
I agree about the disease-spreading part but also they're just really annoying. Those bug zapper rackets do a fantastic job, though
Indeed, we don't even need to wipe out all mosquitoes, not even most, only the malaria carrying ones.
You would maybe love the mosquito zapper racket I used to use when growing up.
I felt like zeus striking the mortal mosquitoes with electricity and also improved my agility and control since it was flimsy product and you don’t want to hit anything with it.
Doesn’t eradicate mosquitoes but sure as hell gave me the feeling of control. :P
You can also use them on fruit flies.
Mosquitoes have their place in the ecosystems - so it would be wise not eradicate some 3000+ species - the consequences could be ... unpredictable.
[flagged]